Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
I've only spent a day with him, but really liked what I saw. Most importantly, he is highly transparent and easy to follow and was very profitable. Albeit, 1 day is not much, but I will update................
Anyone else have experiences in this room? If so, please share.
Ok here is my update as promised. First I will say that Chartsky is the most honest and transparent moderator I have seen in the various rooms I have been in. Today was my 5th day with him. Here are the results: His profit goal is $300-400 per day. Friday - hit profit goal, Monday he lost about 350, Tuesday and Wednesday hit profit goal both days and today was plus $150. So far so good and I'm glad I joined.
Just wanted to update you because I have had a couple of messages. I have decided not to continue with Chartsky. While transparent, he is not consistent enough for me. My first week with him he was profitable, but last week was a losing week for him.
I have just taken the monthly trial with Chartsky for $250 per month.
On the first day he was down $400 on taking trades that, in my opinion, were too early by placing limit orders ahead on the market to catch bounces. They didn't work. Seemed like picking tops and bottoms to where he believes is support and resistance.
After the session he sends this email.
To me it seems lame to blame the market and point outside himself to justify his bad trading. And comparing some random room that lost more than he yesterday is totally ridiculous. Made me laugh because I had a winning day while I traded his losing trades on sim. Apparently he want's thousands of dollars to learn his method of trading off S/R levels with basically a 1:1 risk/reward and moving the stop to BE+1 after it moves 75% to target.
Hey futurestrader -
About my same experience. Ask him about his charts...he told me that they are up just to give the people in the room something to look at while he trades from another chart...LOL I tried to ask him specific questions and he replied that he doesn't answer those type questions. He also didn't open the room a few days because he had to take his grandson to the dr, and didn't let anyone know he was doing that...we sat there wondering what the heck is going on. This guy is something else.
I saw a friend do a trial and I watch it live, here is what I saw.
Review of Charsky room that cost $300/mo.
Cons
a. Always very quickly moving trades around for entries and exits (1 second quick changes)
The trade has to snap in his direction instantly.
b. If a trade doesn't go well within 2 seconds he takes BE or a small loss
c. Doubled up to 6 lots on one trade but wrote it as 2 lots.
d. Complains that volume is low and about HFT computers
e. One day was three losers in a row.
f. Trades 3 lots on each market and for no reason does 4 lots on 6E
Although his site says 1 lot, etc. 1 position is 3 lots/ or 4 lots.
g. Filled to the tick on CL at least 3 or 4 times.
h. Won't say directly that he uses real money.
I. His ninjatrader froze and he yells get out, then gotomeeting suddenly closes.
j. Suddenly closes room on BE or loss
k. does not show DOM, only chart trader, no proof it is real money.
l. Counter trading, Scalps only. Misses and trend of any kind,, like the huge ES drop this week.
m. Too many break even/small losing days.
Pros
b. The risk to reward is okay. You might make money each month.
Everydoby! Don’t waste 1 penny with this con artist. Another scammer in this industry. Today was my 10th day in his room. Guess what? He didn’t take NO ONE SINGLE WINNING TRADE. Just losing trades or BE (remember BE are losing trades too, because of comissions and fees).
According to his website, “we shoot for $300 to $400 a day, per position, in a LIVE! Trading Room”. SIMPLY RIDICULOUS!!! Yeah, NO ONE SINGLE WINNING TRADE in 10 days.
If you lost Money with this criminal, BE IN CONTACT WITH ME. I’m going to guide you how to recuperate your money. Moreover, I’m going to guide you how to complain about him to NFA, CFTC, FBI, spread his reputations to all internet fóruns, social media, etc.
My friend did the trial. It was no good.
Then he left after two or three weeks.
He told Chartsky that he was disappointed and if he could refund any portion.
He forgot the auto Paypal and noticed it later for the second month.
Chartsky would not refund his second month (although he NEVER entered the room)
Chartsky ignored any and all emails!
Another $300 stolen! My friend was too busy with real work to do anymore with the situation or trading again.
