Anyone able to share his experience with this ?
I might consider it for "sleeping money" or for friends and family. What are the pros and cons and the fields you need to pay special care to limit risks ?
I'd be interested to hear from the client side's perspective as well as the "signals provider" side. The best ones seem to make a living out of it from their auto strategies.
The recommended broker to benefit at maximum from this device seems to be "AAA-FX" (only affiliated one). Is it worth it ?
There are so many issues it is unbelievable and they do not fix their own mistakes. I had signal providers putting in 'ghost orders' and all kinds of crap. They owed me about 12K from goof-ups by the end of the day and I got a couple in the range of 8.00, 192.00 and less...
That system will never work because they don't vet their signal providers either.
I think a better bet would be currensee.com and only stick to trade leaders that have tight correlation.
Any idiot can pop on an EA and have at it. They do NO screening and if you look at total pips one on each signal provider you will see very few actually make money in the long run.
You do not get what the provider gets. You will have many orders 'disconnected' or 'shadow trades' which they canceled but your broker refused. Your broker will just 'disconnect' and voila, you lose money.
Most of those clown signal providers have 600 - 1000 pip stops with 5 pips take profit! So, yes, you can modify it to where you have tighter stops, but guess what.
I do believe they have a good concept, I tried, analyzed and vested probably 1,000 hours playing with it and I can tell you that the signal providers you use today will probably not be there the next time there is a big run. They have been around for quite a while and I don't see any of the guys I used from a couple years back still there. Funny how that works. I am sure they are still there, but they have different usernames! All that requires is a new email address!
So, if you want to trade all the FREE and paid EA's on the planet and have some dude from Russia collecting a check, then have at it.
Can you make money off zulutrade, YES!!! Can you lose money off Zulutrade!!! YES!!! And, my bet is on the 2nd one.
Zulutrade is not trading. It is gambling in my opinion.
The following 2 users say Thank You to bluemele for this post:
I tried it as a signal provider using Zulu/AAA-FX demo account therefore using their web interface.
My conclusion is that the web interface is the most awful I ever saw. You cannot set lot sizes therefore you need to place 1 lot orders one at a time... unfortunately, you have to let go 15 seconds between each order.
If you need to react quickly with numerous lots, it becomes such a useless nightmare and such a waste of time and money. Not reactive enough.
I know you can go the MT4 route but coming from NT, I just hate this platform. Piece of crap to me and I never understood why it is so "popular".
It is true most of the all-of-fame comes from reckless trading. The guys advertised most often blew 3 to 5 accounts before reaching the high ranks and earning clients. Which leads unarguably to the question of their integrity about being investment advisors in the long run.
Anyway, better off be a signal provider than a client by miles so you can run your virtual trades free of money and usurpate poor people No seriously, I just realised than if it's nailed with your own proprietary automatic trading it might be a viable option, but if it comes to discretionnary trading, your opponents are so desperate and tricky you might end up losing a lot of time if you don't do this as a full-time job. Some sure do this in a "professionnal" way and earn a excellent wager from it, but it must need a lot of dedication and not much honesty when selling mud to strangers.
Anyway, FXDD live + MT4 would be the choice for me, and Dukascopy to replicate trades.
It seems Zulu is considering porting its technology to futures and CFD ...but it's only talk and promises for now.
Collective2 is already offering the same concept for forex+futures+stocks with endorsement with the most reputable trading softwares (NT is there). However their commissions structure makes no sense to me : you have to "rent" your system, usually for small amounts of money and without any control on the volumes and returns your clients could make. For this only, Zulu seems much more viable about their commissions structure and how it can truely greet someone's labour.
You don't want to reveal your strategies for $1000-$10000 / month.
StrategyExchange lease futures trading systems ....but you have to sell them first to them. No-go...
Rent-A-Signal seem similar to Zulu, kind of like a less popular copy-cat ?
I was almost a signal provider for them as I was in the top 10 for about 5 months. I gave up though as I couldn't work their requirements for trades and also the CFTC/NFA changes w/ Dodd/Frank screwed me up.
They seem to be having a lot of turnover on their signal providers lately... Be cautious.
Like someone said though, there should be separate threads, but I am thinking one thread for all of them wouldn't be a bad idea. Up to the OP.
1. By your posts you are trying to convince yourself that this is a great thing and why you continue to 'trust' it.
2. You work for Zulutrade. I hope not...
I do not care to be convinced about Zulutrade. It is a shite service in my views and I have the lost $'s to prove it. I quantified and calculated about as well as anyone could I would think and at the end of the day, GOOD LUCK! It is a big gamble in my opinion, but so are so many things in life.
Don't mean to be harsh, but this service is a loser in my opinion and not even worth debating. GOOD CONCEPT!
@Eduard Murton, would you please clarify that you do work for Zulutrade or are associated with Zulutrade.
Due to time constraints, please do not PM me if your question can be resolved or answered on the forum.
Need help? 1) Stop changing things. No new indicators, charts, or methods. Be consistent with what is in front of you first. 2) Start a journal and post to it daily with the trades you made to show your strengths and weaknesses. 3) Set goals for yourself to reach daily. Make them about how you trade, not how much money you make. 4) Accept responsibility for your actions. Stop looking elsewhere to explain away poor performance. 5) Where to start as a trader? Watch this webinar and read this thread for hundreds of questions and answers. 6) Help using the forum? Watch this video to learn general tips on using the site.
If you want to support our community, become an Elite Member.
the best service out there for a trader to be successful and profitable
is EDUCATION and KNOWLEDGE.nothing compares to that.
read books,attend webinars and seminars and trust your own self.
get into the game by putting contracts yourself and not someone
you don;t know.
i have heard about zulu trade but i cannot trust anyone with my money...
The following user says Thank You to 327trader for this post: