It was a very nice day today and i did have 2 exits, for really no gain but i seem to have entered at the perfect time for the remaining 3 trades that are still open.
Exit the following trades:
1 ES Long @ 2,053.50; Exit @ 2,055.25 = +$35 - $27.50(fees and commission) = +$7.50
1 NQ Long @ 4,235.50; Exit @ 4,232.50 = -$60 - $12.50(fees and commission) = -$72.50
Trades still open:
1 ES Long @ 1,992.75 = +$3,125
1 NQ Long @ 4,098.50 = +$2,680
1 TF Long @ 1,156.50 = +$3,480
Account Balance: $59,220
I'm very tempted to exit all trades today due to the nice run it has had but i do believe once you have a strategy that works you have to stick to the rules, i can see how that can be very difficult at times.
How are you calculating this? If you have two cars on the same account purchased at different prices they will average out into an avg or hybrid entry price. So your blended entry on the NQ would have been 4167 (or 4235.5 + 4098.50 / 2). And exiting one contract at 4235.50 would have been +$1310 in profit or so.
EDIT: Also are you trading this paper or in a SIM?
The only trades I'm taking for real are the NQ trades everything else is just paper trading, and you're right if i bought two contracts at two prices tradestation would average out the price, but i'm trading two separate strategies into one and i would like to keep the price of one strategy separate of the other, it will give me a better idea of individual performance instead of both of them in one.
The following user says Thank You to Helipilot for this post:
I'm not trying to be rude or anything, just trying to understand.
So the $50K account balance, is that cash or sim? If it is cash then why mix in the p/l from your ES sim trades?
If I was trading multiple strategies I would trade them under different accounts. That way the p/l of that account is directly tied to one strategy.
EDIT: I would not paper trade either, I would setup some demo accounts and use that to test the strategies. At least that way you get closer to the effects of slippage and missed fills. When you paper trade you can say you were entered at a price where you might not of actually gotten filled if you placed a live or sim order them. Sim will not equal live, but it is far closer then paper.
The 50K is paper money and my live trading account is around 15K so i can only really afford to trade up to 2 NQ contracts for now but i keep that separate from what I'm posting here, so really I'm just curious how i would perform if i could trade everything i wanted. When it comes to trading the two separate strategies, they work best when traded together but i am still interested to see during the trades they take together which one for that time was the better performer. All my trades are done with market orders so i don't think the fill will be an issue at least it hasn't been so far trading the NQ my average slippage is anywhere from 0-2 ticks. Maybe your right, maybe i should be doing this on a sim and not a trading journal since i'm not really discussing how i am taking the trades, do you know of a good sim trader i could use that's not tradestation and is free?
I am still confused because if the NQ trades are live, then why are you mixing sim and live profit / loss into the sim $50k balance (above where you stated that it is now $59k)?
If the ES trades are sim and the NQ are live and you are trying to 'hedge' or something of that nature, taking trades in sim is meaningless to your live trades. Odds are you will lose real money in your live account and make bank in sim. SO it doesn't matter if the strategies balance each other out if they are not being traded live together.
I would stop trading live, until you have the cash and ability to trade the strategy the way you need to.
it doesn't matter anymore because im going to be switching over to do this on a sim account but ill try to explain what i was trying to accomplish... i have 2 trading strategies, they both work great on their own but together the equity curve gets a bit smoother, so you can trade one or trade both you will still get good results. I'm not mixing live and sim all i was doing on here was sim. I'm not trying to hedge anything the strategy works on all indexes but the more indexes i trade the more i'm in the market SO if i only trade NQ i'm in the market 40% of the time, if i trade NQ and ES i'm in the market 60%, if i trade NQ, ES, and TF im in the market 70% of the time. Its based on technical analysis and its all been backtested on tradestation and multicharts. The only reason i brought up the live account was to let you guys know i was actually trading this and its not all paper money.
I just read back on some of my earlier replies and i can see what i was saying was very confusing, just take all my comments from before and take out the fact theres a live account, imagine i never said anything about it.