CL & GC Day trading use Indicators, Price action and Fibonacci - futures io
futures io futures trading



CL & GC Day trading use Indicators, Price action and Fibonacci


Discussion in Trading Journals

Updated by BTR411
      Top Posters
    1. looks_one cmmichaels with 17 posts (29 thanks)
    2. looks_two PandaWarrior with 4 posts (20 thanks)
    3. looks_3 sandptrader with 3 posts (3 thanks)
    4. looks_4 xelaar with 2 posts (3 thanks)
      Best Posters
    1. looks_one BTR411 with 6.0 thanks per post
    2. looks_two PandaWarrior with 5.0 thanks per post
    3. looks_3 cmmichaels with 1.7 thanks per post
    4. looks_4 sandptrader with 1.0 thanks per post
    1. trending_up 6,120 views
    2. thumb_up 66 thanks given
    3. group 8 followers
    1. forum 30 replies
    2. attach_file 25 attachments




Welcome to futures io: the largest futures trading community on the planet, with well over 100,000 members
  • Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
  • Quality education from leading professional traders
  • We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
  • We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
  • We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community.  It's free and simple.

-- Big Mike, Site Administrator

(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)

 
Search this Thread
 

CL & GC Day trading use Indicators, Price action and Fibonacci

(login for full post details)
  #21 (permalink)
In the heat
 
Experience: None
Platform: Tradeovate
Trading: Energy
 
PandaWarrior's Avatar
 
Posts: 3,162 since Mar 2010
Thanks: 6,324 given, 13,368 received

@cmmichaels,

I have some thoughts....I was bored tonight so thought I would read some threads I normally dont and yours came up.

Hope you don't mind me sticking my nose in your business...but here goes...

1. I'm not sure what your rules are but it does seem like you are trading by the seat of your pants based on what I see on your charts....things like "I felt like it would do "x" and "I thought this looked like "x" set up". To me, it looks random....with little or no consistency.

2. Indicators. I like them too, and you have a lot of them...to many for me but I understand....now about those indicators. You've mentioned the MACD only once or twice, the stoch once, the pivot levels once or twice....and the fibs not at all. You have however, mentioned the Moving Averages quite a bit. Now the question, do you use all these indicators as input when deciding to enter a trade? If so, how often do you second guess yourself based on so many indicators? And now the real question, which one(s) can you live without and which ones would you kill to keep on the chart?

3. Moving averages: I have a suggestion regarding their use...take it for what its worth.....Stop shorting above the MA stack and stop buying below the stack and for god's sake, stop trading in between the stack.....just let the market come to you....truth is, MA's are the only indicators I've found any real use for and you don't need them at all once you get used to how price flows....but they are useful and I think you can make a killing using them....But obey some basic rules. Now you might say, But Pandawarrior, I think this huge spike is an exhaustion bar and its going to come off" and you might be right. But did you just make 80-90 ticks on the long that lined up correctly above the MA stack? If so, why fight the trend and sell into a long environment.....I recognize its a valid trade idea, but you are fighting the trend....and if you try to swing for the fences, you will eventually run into the larger buyers just waiting to buy the pull backs and the short you are sweating over will get ran over. Go with the flow baby!

4. Several times you have mentioned you screwed up your stops. I can only guess your initial stop is to tight, fix that ASAP by changing it to something much larger....then you can tighten it up if you need to, but never go into a situation that needs a 25 tick stop with a 15 tick initial stop.....you might get hit before you have the chance to modify it....so fix it immediately.

5. Quit trying to trade every damn wiggle in the market. You have an excellent MA set up.....use it. Don't buy until you can see the fear in the short's eyes...then buy with your maximum fire power.

6. Last but not least, learn to respect the idea of knowing when to quit....both for your stops....ie, don't let your largest losing day exceed your largest winning day...that really sucks....and also for your profits....a floor trader I know said he'd have made exponentially more money in his career if he'd stopped trading after the first two hours.....fully 1/3 of the days gains and sometimes more were given back in the afternoon....lots of reasons for this...too much to go into here but suffice to say, make 30-100 ticks in the morning and go home. Keep your cash. Its not about being right...its about making and KEEPING money.

Ok, thats enough from me...hope it helps and if it doesn't you can ban me from your thread...

Cheers.

Brian

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, Leonardo da Vinci


Most people chose unhappiness over uncertainty, Tim Ferris
Reply With Quote
The following 15 users say Thank You to PandaWarrior for this post:

Can you help answer these questions
from other members on futures io?
Delta PVP ( POC )
MultiCharts
converting useful Pine Script into Multicharts code
EasyLanguage Programming
Historical option expirations
Brokers
Convert H Data TS to NT
NinjaTrader
Order Data Export Plugin-- Is it possible?
NinjaTrader
 
 
(login for full post details)
  #22 (permalink)
London England
 
Experience: Beginner
Platform: Metatrader
Trading: Spot $
 
Posts: 90 since Apr 2012
Thanks: 1,075 given, 134 received


sandptrader View Post
@cmmichael's.......I can see your trying hard to get your Trading Plan together based on your daily evaluation, and what you need to improve on.
I also trade both these markets and they are big movers, and not so easy to get your stops in the right place at times.
I usually use a smaller Renko bar size 3 or 4 ...for Entry and Stop placement and keeping an eye on the Larger Intraday charts, about the same as what you are doing here.
Your doing Great on your Evaluation, and all i can say is protect your capital best you can.
I am also continuing daily evaluation of trades, and what i miss.
Good Luck in your trading.

Hi sandptrader thanks for the feedback really appreciate it, I've never looked at renko bars so maybe I'll do a bit of research into them for refining entries. My stop placement has definitely been off but as you mentioned this journal can really help me review my trades and find a more optimal stop placement area. It's a tricky one when you are learning because when I am completely wrong which clearly happens the tight stops really help. It is obviously a work in progress at the moment. What sort of stop size do you use on GC mainly if you don't mind me asking? Before when I used to trade I used an emergancy stop but I found that the discipline to have to close the trade manually was difficult and it also meant my r multiples were really bad.

Good luck with your trading as well, and please stop by anytime.

Mike

Visit my futures io Trade Journal Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to cmmichaels for this post:
 
(login for full post details)
  #23 (permalink)
London England
 
Experience: Beginner
Platform: Metatrader
Trading: Spot $
 
Posts: 90 since Apr 2012
Thanks: 1,075 given, 134 received



PandaWarrior View Post
@cmmichaels,

I have some thoughts....I was bored tonight so thought I would read some threads I normally dont and yours came up.

Hope you don't mind me sticking my nose in your business...but here goes...

1. I'm not sure what your rules are but it does seem like you are trading by the seat of your pants based on what I see on your charts....things like "I felt like it would do "x" and "I thought this looked like "x" set up". To me, it looks random....with little or no consistency.

2. Indicators. I like them too, and you have a lot of them...to many for me but I understand....now about those indicators. You've mentioned the MACD only once or twice, the stoch once, the pivot levels once or twice....and the fibs not at all. You have however, mentioned the Moving Averages quite a bit. Now the question, do you use all these indicators as input when deciding to enter a trade? If so, how often do you second guess yourself based on so many indicators? And now the real question, which one(s) can you live without and which ones would you kill to keep on the chart?

3. Moving averages: I have a suggestion regarding their use...take it for what its worth.....Stop shorting above the MA stack and stop buying below the stack and for god's sake, stop trading in between the stack.....just let the market come to you....truth is, MA's are the only indicators I've found any real use for and you don't need them at all once you get used to how price flows....but they are useful and I think you can make a killing using them....But obey some basic rules. Now you might say, But Pandawarrior, I think this huge spike is an exhaustion bar and its going to come off" and you might be right. But did you just make 80-90 ticks on the long that lined up correctly above the MA stack? If so, why fight the trend and sell into a long environment.....I recognize its a valid trade idea, but you are fighting the trend....and if you try to swing for the fences, you will eventually run into the larger buyers just waiting to buy the pull backs and the short you are sweating over will get ran over. Go with the flow baby!

4. Several times you have mentioned you screwed up your stops. I can only guess your initial stop is to tight, fix that ASAP by changing it to something much larger....then you can tighten it up if you need to, but never go into a situation that needs a 25 tick stop with a 15 tick initial stop.....you might get hit before you have the chance to modify it....so fix it immediately.

5. Quit trying to trade every damn wiggle in the market. You have an excellent MA set up.....use it. Don't buy until you can see the fear in the short's eyes...then buy with your maximum fire power.

6. Last but not least, learn to respect the idea of knowing when to quit....both for your stops....ie, don't let your largest losing day exceed your largest winning day...that really sucks....and also for your profits....a floor trader I know said he'd have made exponentially more money in his career if he'd stopped trading after the first two hours.....fully 1/3 of the days gains and sometimes more were given back in the afternoon....lots of reasons for this...too much to go into here but suffice to say, make 30-100 ticks in the morning and go home. Keep your cash. Its not about being right...its about making and KEEPING money.

Ok, thats enough from me...hope it helps and if it doesn't you can ban me from your thread...

Cheers.

Brian

Ban you... definitely not you have a VIP pass any feedback is really appreciated and thanks for taking the time to give such a detailed response. Same for anyone else reading the thread any comments whatever they maybe are all welcome. I'll try and address the points you've mentioned and give my thoughts.

Before I answer the questions I think I should put some context round it which I hope will mean my answers make a bit more sense. I think that right now I am in a phase where I can understand roughly what is going on during the day in the market and now with this new understanding comes a bit of over confidence its like another phase I guess that you go through. The transition from not having a clue what you are doing to being able to some days see a lot of the action before it happens has caused over-trading/trying to attack everything too much with out a refined execution strategy. My execution is terrible at times but I think I will soon get over this as the novelty will wear off but this is pretty much the mindset I'm in at the moment.

1. I'm not sure what your rules are but it does seem like you are trading by the seat of your pants based on what I see on your charts....things like "I felt like it would do "x" and "I thought this looked like "x" set up". To me, it looks random....with little or no consistency.
Fair point, to me this is the big struggle of trying to become a discretionary trader, I'm not a mechanical trader so I don't have rules that say if this candle closed hear and x y and z happens then place the trade. I'm trying to read each day as it comes and trade around the orderflow/price action. I have certain set-ups but every trade I take whether it works or not I'm still not 100% because they all look different and they all have different context so I'm just trying to find the right locations in the context of the day. Every successful discretionary day trader I've seen seems to see a set up and always be in some doubt around it and everyone gets stopped out. It never is crystal clear I think this is the part that just takes time, I'm not sure how I can go about refining this without simply putting in more screen time. Maybe there are better processes I can put in place to address these issues I'm not sure?

2. Indicators. I like them too, and you have a lot of them...to many for me but I understand....now about those indicators. You've mentioned the MACD only once or twice, the stoch once, the pivot levels once or twice....and the fibs not at all. You have however, mentioned the Moving Averages quite a bit. Now the question, do you use all these indicators as input when deciding to enter a trade? If so, how often do you second guess yourself based on so many indicators? And now the real question, which one(s) can you live without and which ones would you kill to keep on the chart?
This is very true and has become more apparent recently, I've realised that my focus has changed slightly over the past couple of weeks. For the previous few months I was hugely focused on the MACD then the Stochs. Recently I find I'm looking at them much less and really just analysing the candles more in terms of whose trapped and whose getting taken out next. Also the moving averages I definitely couldn't live without right now I use them massively, I analyse the context of the day around the averages really in every way possible, how far price has travelled away from the averages which one is price struggling to get through etc. I don't find I second guess myself much with the indicators I use them more as confluence so if its an area and then something is lining up with one of my indicators then things are looking good. I'm not really looking for them all to come together because that doesn't happen really its more they all have a purpose at certain times. The fibs I was using a lot but now I'm not at all because I wasn't getting them to work properly and there seems to be bigger things to focus on. It feels like when I'm learning you just sub-consciously just focus on one thing at a time because that's all your brain can digest.

So really to answer your question I'm not sure if I want to get rid of any at the moment because I don't find having too many is hindering me its more that I'm just not really using them all as much as I could but I think as my experience builds they will all play a role. Obviously I could be completely wrong and maybe I should just have 1 and I'm going to find this it out the hard way.

3. Moving averages: I have a suggestion regarding their use...take it for what its worth.....Stop shorting above the MA stack and stop buying below the stack and for god's sake, stop trading in between the stack.....just let the market come to you....truth is, MA's are the only indicators I've found any real use for and you don't need them at all once you get used to how price flows....but they are useful and I think you can make a killing using them....But obey some basic rules. Now you might say, But Pandawarrior, I think this huge spike is an exhaustion bar and its going to come off" and you might be right. But did you just make 80-90 ticks on the long that lined up correctly above the MA stack? If so, why fight the trend and sell into a long environment.....I recognize its a valid trade idea, but you are fighting the trend....and if you try to swing for the fences, you will eventually run into the larger buyers just waiting to buy the pull backs and the short you are sweating over will get ran over. Go with the flow baby!

This is great advice and something I've been journaling about and monitoring the position of the MAs to my trades, certainly reviewing my journal if I had just traded in the overall direction I would be in a better position. I think the reasons for this are probably back to the first thing I said about the mindset I'm currently in and also I think I just do the usual beginner trader error still of always looking for the market to reverse and catching the reversal. This needs to be one of my main priorities now. By the moving average stack I assume you mean when the averages are converging? Did you have this problem? Is that how you filtered all your bad trades by only trading with your MAs?

4. Several times you have mentioned you screwed up your stops. I can only guess your initial stop is to tight, fix that ASAP by changing it to something much larger....then you can tighten it up if you need to, but never go into a situation that needs a 25 tick stop with a 15 tick initial stop.....you might get hit before you have the chance to modify it....so fix it immediately.

Yes you are absolutely right this doesn't happen that often but Thursday it did a lot the whole day I was just off making careless mistakes etc again this needs to be addressed but you are right get the stop wider then bring it in is definitely the right way round.

5. Quit trying to trade every damn wiggle in the market. You have an excellent MA set up.....use it. Don't buy until you can see the fear in the short's eyes...then buy with your maximum fire power.
Yes again this is the focus and I think this will naturally calm down a bit after the excitement of understanding things a bit more has worn off at the moment when I predict a move and it happens and I don't capitalise I feel worse than I do when I lose money. I think this is part of this period I am in at the moment, I'm so glad that I predicted the move and I'm finally understanding things I'm devastated I missed it, I'm sure this will wear off as hopefully my understanding and consistency improves.

6. Last but not least, learn to respect the idea of knowing when to quit....both for your stops....ie, don't let your largest losing day exceed your largest winning day...that really sucks....and also for your profits....a floor trader I know said he'd have made exponentially more money in his career if he'd stopped trading after the first two hours.....fully 1/3 of the days gains and sometimes more were given back in the afternoon....lots of reasons for this...too much to go into here but suffice to say, make 30-100 ticks in the morning and go home. Keep your cash. Its not about being right...its about making and KEEPING money.

My losing days have been bigger, I have a full stop out level that I slightly went over on Thursday but other than that I've kept below by trading small size. I think with regards to reviewing when I'm trading at my best will come later when I have a bigger sample size but I will keep on this.

Thanks again for taking the time to give me so much excellent advise hopefully what I've written makes some kind of sense I don't know if you can relate to maybe this phase I am in at the moment, hopefully I'll be able to move past this soon.

Visit my futures io Trade Journal Reply With Quote
The following 2 users say Thank You to cmmichaels for this post:
 
(login for full post details)
  #24 (permalink)
Valdosta, GA. U.S.A
 
Experience: Advanced
Platform: Sierra , TOS
Trading: 6E, ES, CL, GC
 
Posts: 498 since Sep 2010
Thanks: 1,880 given, 472 received

Well when i Trade GC i use 15 ticks and for CL 12 ticks, i can do this with the smaller Renko type bars.
I am looking at sizes 3 and 4 to get my Entries,
On another note, i am trying to view too many size charts on my current monitor, as i switch from one market to the other GC & CL with all the size charts i have set up to view them both causes me to miss many trades and that brings me to this point.
I need more monitors to see a Complete view in my opinion of the 2 markets.
This is my current situation.
Just like you are working on getting everything in order for your Trading, i am also working on my issues i would like to improve on.
We have to keep improving what we can to be Successful.
It is a Challenge for everyone i believe, to get it right.
Try BetterRenko or any type Renko here at futures.io (formerly BMT) for this purpose, and test it out till you get use to the Renko bars as they are not time based.
Here are 2 charts of CL using size 4 Renko bars, and you can see the Entries can be tight stops.

Attached Thumbnails
Click image for larger version

Name:	CL 10-13 (4 BetterRenko)  9_6_2013.jpg
Views:	102
Size:	123.0 KB
ID:	122679   Click image for larger version

Name:	CL 10-13 (4 BetterRenko)  9_6_2013b.jpg
Views:	88
Size:	118.4 KB
ID:	122680  
Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to sandptrader for this post:
 
(login for full post details)
  #25 (permalink)
Valdosta, GA. U.S.A
 
Experience: Advanced
Platform: Sierra , TOS
Trading: 6E, ES, CL, GC
 
Posts: 498 since Sep 2010
Thanks: 1,880 given, 472 received

I was just reading the above post, and i do agree if you use tight Stops you could get hit real soon.
i have to say Entries with tight Stops are not easy, and it is a Dilemma we are facing to what we are willing to risk on the particular setup we are looking at entering.
So that's why we have to initially tru trial get this figured out.
All these posts from everyone are to be viewed as helpful, no matter how it may sound.
View everything as Technical.
We are all friends trying to help one another.

Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to sandptrader for this post:
 
(login for full post details)
  #26 (permalink)
In the heat
 
Experience: None
Platform: Tradeovate
Trading: Energy
 
PandaWarrior's Avatar
 
Posts: 3,162 since Mar 2010
Thanks: 6,324 given, 13,368 received


cmmichaels View Post
Ban you... definitely not you have a VIP pass any feedback is really appreciated and thanks for taking the time to give such a detailed response. Same for anyone else reading the thread any comments whatever they maybe are all welcome. I'll try and address the points you've mentioned and give my thoughts.

Before I answer the questions I think I should put some context round it which I hope will mean my answers make a bit more sense. I think that right now I am in a phase where I can understand roughly what is going on during the day in the market and now with this new understanding comes a bit of over confidence its like another phase I guess that you go through. The transition from not having a clue what you are doing to being able to some days see a lot of the action before it happens has caused over-trading/trying to attack everything too much with out a refined execution strategy. My execution is terrible at times but I think I will soon get over this as the novelty will wear off but this is pretty much the mindset I'm in at the moment.

1. I'm not sure what your rules are but it does seem like you are trading by the seat of your pants based on what I see on your charts....things like "I felt like it would do "x" and "I thought this looked like "x" set up". To me, it looks random....with little or no consistency.
Fair point, to me this is the big struggle of trying to become a discretionary trader, I'm not a mechanical trader so I don't have rules that say if this candle closed hear and x y and z happens then place the trade. I'm trying to read each day as it comes and trade around the orderflow/price action. I have certain set-ups but every trade I take whether it works or not I'm still not 100% because they all look different and they all have different context so I'm just trying to find the right locations in the context of the day. Every successful discretionary day trader I've seen seems to see a set up and always be in some doubt around it and everyone gets stopped out. It never is crystal clear I think this is the part that just takes time, I'm not sure how I can go about refining this without simply putting in more screen time. Maybe there are better processes I can put in place to address these issues I'm not sure?

2. Indicators. I like them too, and you have a lot of them...to many for me but I understand....now about those indicators. You've mentioned the MACD only once or twice, the stoch once, the pivot levels once or twice....and the fibs not at all. You have however, mentioned the Moving Averages quite a bit. Now the question, do you use all these indicators as input when deciding to enter a trade? If so, how often do you second guess yourself based on so many indicators? And now the real question, which one(s) can you live without and which ones would you kill to keep on the chart?
This is very true and has become more apparent recently, I've realised that my focus has changed slightly over the past couple of weeks. For the previous few months I was hugely focused on the MACD then the Stochs. Recently I find I'm looking at them much less and really just analysing the candles more in terms of whose trapped and whose getting taken out next. Also the moving averages I definitely couldn't live without right now I use them massively, I analyse the context of the day around the averages really in every way possible, how far price has travelled away from the averages which one is price struggling to get through etc. I don't find I second guess myself much with the indicators I use them more as confluence so if its an area and then something is lining up with one of my indicators then things are looking good. I'm not really looking for them all to come together because that doesn't happen really its more they all have a purpose at certain times. The fibs I was using a lot but now I'm not at all because I wasn't getting them to work properly and there seems to be bigger things to focus on. It feels like when I'm learning you just sub-consciously just focus on one thing at a time because that's all your brain can digest.

So really to answer your question I'm not sure if I want to get rid of any at the moment because I don't find having too many is hindering me its more that I'm just not really using them all as much as I could but I think as my experience builds they will all play a role. Obviously I could be completely wrong and maybe I should just have 1 and I'm going to find this it out the hard way.

3. Moving averages: I have a suggestion regarding their use...take it for what its worth.....Stop shorting above the MA stack and stop buying below the stack and for god's sake, stop trading in between the stack.....just let the market come to you....truth is, MA's are the only indicators I've found any real use for and you don't need them at all once you get used to how price flows....but they are useful and I think you can make a killing using them....But obey some basic rules. Now you might say, But Pandawarrior, I think this huge spike is an exhaustion bar and its going to come off" and you might be right. But did you just make 80-90 ticks on the long that lined up correctly above the MA stack? If so, why fight the trend and sell into a long environment.....I recognize its a valid trade idea, but you are fighting the trend....and if you try to swing for the fences, you will eventually run into the larger buyers just waiting to buy the pull backs and the short you are sweating over will get ran over. Go with the flow baby!

This is great advice and something I've been journaling about and monitoring the position of the MAs to my trades, certainly reviewing my journal if I had just traded in the overall direction I would be in a better position. I think the reasons for this are probably back to the first thing I said about the mindset I'm currently in and also I think I just do the usual beginner trader error still of always looking for the market to reverse and catching the reversal. This needs to be one of my main priorities now. By the moving average stack I assume you mean when the averages are converging? Did you have this problem? Is that how you filtered all your bad trades by only trading with your MAs?

4. Several times you have mentioned you screwed up your stops. I can only guess your initial stop is to tight, fix that ASAP by changing it to something much larger....then you can tighten it up if you need to, but never go into a situation that needs a 25 tick stop with a 15 tick initial stop.....you might get hit before you have the chance to modify it....so fix it immediately.

Yes you are absolutely right this doesn't happen that often but Thursday it did a lot the whole day I was just off making careless mistakes etc again this needs to be addressed but you are right get the stop wider then bring it in is definitely the right way round.

5. Quit trying to trade every damn wiggle in the market. You have an excellent MA set up.....use it. Don't buy until you can see the fear in the short's eyes...then buy with your maximum fire power.
Yes again this is the focus and I think this will naturally calm down a bit after the excitement of understanding things a bit more has worn off at the moment when I predict a move and it happens and I don't capitalise I feel worse than I do when I lose money. I think this is part of this period I am in at the moment, I'm so glad that I predicted the move and I'm finally understanding things I'm devastated I missed it, I'm sure this will wear off as hopefully my understanding and consistency improves.

6. Last but not least, learn to respect the idea of knowing when to quit....both for your stops....ie, don't let your largest losing day exceed your largest winning day...that really sucks....and also for your profits....a floor trader I know said he'd have made exponentially more money in his career if he'd stopped trading after the first two hours.....fully 1/3 of the days gains and sometimes more were given back in the afternoon....lots of reasons for this...too much to go into here but suffice to say, make 30-100 ticks in the morning and go home. Keep your cash. Its not about being right...its about making and KEEPING money.

My losing days have been bigger, I have a full stop out level that I slightly went over on Thursday but other than that I've kept below by trading small size. I think with regards to reviewing when I'm trading at my best will come later when I have a bigger sample size but I will keep on this.

Thanks again for taking the time to give me so much excellent advise hopefully what I've written makes some kind of sense I don't know if you can relate to maybe this phase I am in at the moment, hopefully I'll be able to move past this soon.

I'm on my phone reading this tonight. I'll have to respond later on when I get back to my keyboard. There's to much to type with my thumbs!

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, Leonardo da Vinci


Most people chose unhappiness over uncertainty, Tim Ferris
Reply With Quote
 
(login for full post details)
  #27 (permalink)
In the heat
 
Experience: None
Platform: Tradeovate
Trading: Energy
 
PandaWarrior's Avatar
 
Posts: 3,162 since Mar 2010
Thanks: 6,324 given, 13,368 received


cmmichaels View Post
Ban you... definitely not you have a VIP pass any feedback is really appreciated and thanks for taking the time to give such a detailed response. Same for anyone else reading the thread any comments whatever they maybe are all welcome. I'll try and address the points you've mentioned and give my thoughts.

Before I answer the questions I think I should put some context round it which I hope will mean my answers make a bit more sense. I think that right now I am in a phase where I can understand roughly what is going on during the day in the market and now with this new understanding comes a bit of over confidence its like another phase I guess that you go through. The transition from not having a clue what you are doing to being able to some days see a lot of the action before it happens has caused over-trading/trying to attack everything too much with out a refined execution strategy. My execution is terrible at times but I think I will soon get over this as the novelty will wear off but this is pretty much the mindset I'm in at the moment.


Fair point, to me this is the big struggle of trying to become a discretionary trader, I'm not a mechanical trader so I don't have rules that say if this candle closed hear and x y and z happens then place the trade. I'm trying to read each day as it comes and trade around the orderflow/price action. I have certain set-ups but every trade I take whether it works or not I'm still not 100% because they all look different and they all have different context so I'm just trying to find the right locations in the context of the day. Every successful discretionary day trader I've seen seems to see a set up and always be in some doubt around it and everyone gets stopped out. It never is crystal clear I think this is the part that just takes time, I'm not sure how I can go about refining this without simply putting in more screen time. Maybe there are better processes I can put in place to address these issues I'm not sure?

Context is always the same. It might look a little different but the successful trader looks for certain clues, places them in the context of what they know about how price moves and develops guidelines for operating within those guidelines. You should as well. The trader that tries to "wing it" will not succeed.

2. Indicators. I like them too, and you have a lot of them...to many for me but I understand....now about those indicators. You've mentioned the MACD only once or twice, the stoch once, the pivot levels once or twice....and the fibs not at all. You have however, mentioned the Moving Averages quite a bit. Now the question, do you use all these indicators as input when deciding to enter a trade? If so, how often do you second guess yourself based on so many indicators? And now the real question, which one(s) can you live without and which ones would you kill to keep on the chart?
This is very true and has become more apparent recently, I've realised that my focus has changed slightly over the past couple of weeks. For the previous few months I was hugely focused on the MACD then the Stochs. Recently I find I'm looking at them much less and really just analysing the candles more in terms of whose trapped and whose getting taken out next. Also the moving averages I definitely couldn't live without right now I use them massively, I analyse the context of the day around the averages really in every way possible, how far price has travelled away from the averages which one is price struggling to get through etc. I don't find I second guess myself much with the indicators I use them more as confluence so if its an area and then something is lining up with one of my indicators then things are looking good. I'm not really looking for them all to come together because that doesn't happen really its more they all have a purpose at certain times. The fibs I was using a lot but now I'm not at all because I wasn't getting them to work properly and there seems to be bigger things to focus on. It feels like when I'm learning you just sub-consciously just focus on one thing at a time because that's all your brain can digest.

So really to answer your question I'm not sure if I want to get rid of any at the moment because I don't find having too many is hindering me its more that I'm just not really using them all as much as I could but I think as my experience builds they will all play a role. Obviously I could be completely wrong and maybe I should just have 1 and I'm going to find this it out the hard way.

The question is which ones can you live without...not are they hindering you. If you don't use them, for God's sake take them off.

3. Moving averages: I have a suggestion regarding their use...take it for what its worth.....Stop shorting above the MA stack and stop buying below the stack and for god's sake, stop trading in between the stack.....just let the market come to you....truth is, MA's are the only indicators I've found any real use for and you don't need them at all once you get used to how price flows....but they are useful and I think you can make a killing using them....But obey some basic rules. Now you might say, But Pandawarrior, I think this huge spike is an exhaustion bar and its going to come off" and you might be right. But did you just make 80-90 ticks on the long that lined up correctly above the MA stack? If so, why fight the trend and sell into a long environment.....I recognize its a valid trade idea, but you are fighting the trend....and if you try to swing for the fences, you will eventually run into the larger buyers just waiting to buy the pull backs and the short you are sweating over will get ran over. Go with the flow baby!

This is great advice and something I've been journaling about and monitoring the position of the MAs to my trades, certainly reviewing my journal if I had just traded in the overall direction I would be in a better position. I think the reasons for this are probably back to the first thing I said about the mindset I'm currently in and also I think I just do the usual beginner trader error still of always looking for the market to reverse and catching the reversal. This needs to be one of my main priorities now. By the moving average stack I assume you mean when the averages are converging? Did you have this problem? Is that how you filtered all your bad trades by only trading with your MAs?

Beginners always look for the next reversal because they missed the last one. They "predict" something, the market validates them and they fail to execute. If you think somethings going to happen, act on it. With regards to the MA stack, I mean, if you are a trend trader, then a MA stack is great...trade only when all the MA's are in the correct order. Shortest MA on top, followed in succession down to the longest MA on bottom....its a common and accepted way of trading trends and I find it usually occurs just as stops are getting ready to be puked out. Not always of course but often times it will....and you get the stop orders fueling your initial run. Very pleasant when it happens. As to filtering out bad trades, I need to make some points here:

1. Stop worrying about so called filters. You can filter yourself into not taking any trades.
2. There is no such thing as a bad trade. There is however, very bad decisions to trade or not to trade within the context of your trading plan. Losing trades happen no matter how hard you try to filter them or how good your trading plan is. A bad trade is one you took or did not take outside the context of your plan. If your plan says take the reversals and you don't, thats a bad trade.


4. Several times you have mentioned you screwed up your stops. I can only guess your initial stop is to tight, fix that ASAP by changing it to something much larger....then you can tighten it up if you need to, but never go into a situation that needs a 25 tick stop with a 15 tick initial stop.....you might get hit before you have the chance to modify it....so fix it immediately.

Yes you are absolutely right this doesn't happen that often but Thursday it did a lot the whole day I was just off making careless mistakes etc again this needs to be addressed but you are right get the stop wider then bring it in is definitely the right way round.

Have you fixed this yet?

5. Quit trying to trade every damn wiggle in the market. You have an excellent MA set up.....use it. Don't buy until you can see the fear in the short's eyes...then buy with your maximum fire power.
Yes again this is the focus and I think this will naturally calm down a bit after the excitement of understanding things a bit more has worn off at the moment when I predict a move and it happens and I don't capitalise I feel worse than I do when I lose money. I think this is part of this period I am in at the moment, I'm so glad that I predicted the move and I'm finally understanding things I'm devastated I missed it, I'm sure this will wear off as hopefully my understanding and consistency improves.

Predicting moves is for losers. As traders, we forecast probability, not certainty. Get used to operating in the dark. Have a plan if price does "X" and a plan if it does the opposite. If you stop predicting, you'll stop beating yourself up over missing it when you are "right". Which incidentally is not always a good thing. If you begin every trade with the idea that you are wrong and the market must prove you right, you will go a long way towards securing longevity in this business.

6. Last but not least, learn to respect the idea of knowing when to quit....both for your stops....ie, don't let your largest losing day exceed your largest winning day...that really sucks....and also for your profits....a floor trader I know said he'd have made exponentially more money in his career if he'd stopped trading after the first two hours.....fully 1/3 of the days gains and sometimes more were given back in the afternoon....lots of reasons for this...too much to go into here but suffice to say, make 30-100 ticks in the morning and go home. Keep your cash. Its not about being right...its about making and KEEPING money.

My losing days have been bigger, I have a full stop out level that I slightly went over on Thursday but other than that I've kept below by trading small size. I think with regards to reviewing when I'm trading at my best will come later when I have a bigger sample size but I will keep on this.

Thanks again for taking the time to give me so much excellent advise hopefully what I've written makes some kind of sense I don't know if you can relate to maybe this phase I am in at the moment, hopefully I'll be able to move past this soon.

Of course I can relate, thats why I'm here, trying to save you some pain....up to you to listen or not.

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, Leonardo da Vinci


Most people chose unhappiness over uncertainty, Tim Ferris
Reply With Quote
The following 4 users say Thank You to PandaWarrior for this post:
 
(login for full post details)
  #28 (permalink)
London England
 
Experience: Beginner
Platform: Metatrader
Trading: Spot $
 
Posts: 90 since Apr 2012
Thanks: 1,075 given, 134 received

Its been a wild week mainly bad then today I hit a crazy trade that I was actually in double size to normal and made back everything I'd lost since I started this journal and more. It was lucky really someone must have hit the market with a massive sell because GC just tanked over 100 ticks in a second. Overall my trading has been bad I need to review at the weekend read @PandaWarrior 's advice and try and get some more structure and rules to my trading. Glad I've got this journal so I can go back and review everything very helpful.

Results

Tuesday -82
Wednesday -60
Thursday +166

Attached Thumbnails
Click image for larger version

Name:	10-09-2013 GC 5 min.jpg
Views:	67
Size:	405.2 KB
ID:	123216   Click image for larger version

Name:	11-09-2013 GC 5min.jpg
Views:	50
Size:	430.6 KB
ID:	123217   Click image for larger version

Name:	12-09-2013 GC 5min.jpg
Views:	49
Size:	420.1 KB
ID:	123218  
Visit my futures io Trade Journal Reply With Quote
The following 4 users say Thank You to cmmichaels for this post:
 
(login for full post details)
  #29 (permalink)
In the heat
 
Experience: None
Platform: Tradeovate
Trading: Energy
 
PandaWarrior's Avatar
 
Posts: 3,162 since Mar 2010
Thanks: 6,324 given, 13,368 received


cmmichaels View Post
Its been a wild week mainly bad then today I hit a crazy trade that I was actually in double size to normal and made back everything I'd lost since I started this journal and more. It was lucky really someone must have hit the market with a massive sell because GC just tanked over 100 ticks in a second. Overall my trading has been bad I need to review at the weekend read @PandaWarrior 's advice and try and get some more structure and rules to my trading. Glad I've got this journal so I can go back and review everything very helpful.

Results

Tuesday -82
Wednesday -60
Thursday +166






Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, Leonardo da Vinci


Most people chose unhappiness over uncertainty, Tim Ferris
Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to PandaWarrior for this post:
 
(login for full post details)
  #30 (permalink)
London England
 
Experience: Beginner
Platform: Metatrader
Trading: Spot $
 
Posts: 90 since Apr 2012
Thanks: 1,075 given, 134 received


Thanks again @PandaWarrior for the excellent feedback I really appreciate it, even just hearing someone say good trade really helps as learning how to do this can be a fairly lonely endeavour so getting this advice is priceless. Thank you.

So I thought I would start to do some stats. for my journal so far to try and drill down on what's going wrong and after the advice from PW have a look at just how much the counter trend trades are hurting me. I'm pretty blown away with the results, first of all I found it a really enjoyable process and something that I am now going to really develop on in the future. I've started to do stats. for a lot of different aspects of my trading, I knew that the counter trend trades were hurting me a bit but I had no idea to this extent. Below I've attached just a couple of charts that I put together just using some simple trend defining techniques. One is slightly longer term one is a more shorter term trend definition but either way the results are pretty clear, you down need to be a qualified statistician to see what's going on here. Now I can see why FT71 is so hot on this subject when you see the results laid out like this it makes such a difference.

Lots more work to do but I'm happy with what I'm finding so far, thanks again PW. What it basically spells out to me is what I want to be focusing on is good trade location in line with the current trend with a reasonable stop, if I keep hitting these trades the profits should take care of themselves. Also with my stats a lot of the with trend losers were from bad stop placement and would have worked out I would say around 50% of them. Then the rest of them were when I was trying to get short with the trend but it went in to a really tight channel got to a certain point then tanked. I was trying to short it all the way up but again it just shows you need to be patient for the right location then hit it.

Attached Thumbnails
Click image for larger version

Name:	stats.png
Views:	43
Size:	13.3 KB
ID:	123412  
Visit my futures io Trade Journal Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to cmmichaels for this post:


futures io Trading Community Trading Journals > CL & GC Day trading use Indicators, Price action and Fibonacci


September 16, 2013


Upcoming Webinars and Events
 

Bookmap

Nov TBD
     



Copyright © 2020 by futures io, s.a., Av Ricardo J. Alfaro, Century Tower, Panama, +507 833-9432, info@futures.io
All information is for educational use only and is not investment advice.
There is a substantial risk of loss in trading commodity futures, stocks, options and foreign exchange products. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
no new posts