Ok, firstly, I am not an expert, just expounding on what I think is 'right' or more 'right' than 'wrong'. There are no right's and wrong's and it is up to you to decide to take it. However, if you do not heed my advice, then comments get weaker and weaker over time. So, you can choose to heed, or not, no worries either way and you decide if you like them or not. My guess is that you will not like many of the comments but will come back later in time and adapt them. (IF YOU KEEP AT THE SAME SYSTEM!)
I will break your trading down into the GOOD, the BAD, and the UGLY:
Firstly, the Ugly:
1. Why do you need your DOM
on your screen? Please explain as to me it adds
absolutely NO VALUE except a bunch of numbers moving very quickly to distract you.
2. Why do you need a volume chart on your screen. These are tick charts, so to me, you have your volume up/down screaming at you with each bar. If volume is light then bars slow down, if volume is heavy, bars speed up. If there is a lot of down volume, bars go down, if there is a lot of buying, guess what.
3. Your dot should be on the active bar for the price. Whether it be an SMA
1 or whatever, the little dot should be NOT on bar close. Because it could be a very long bar and a lot of movement and you have to look at your price marker to the right to figure that out.
4. I would remove any price markers besides actual price on the right side of your screen. Just more noise. Keltner tends to have price settings etc..
5. I believe chart trader would help you out. You have heard that before.
6. Your 144 MACD takes up too much space. Go ahead and stretch it out by holding cntrl key and adjusting on right column if you want that space. To me you want more room for price action
, fibs, trendlines etc..
7. Turn the centerline to black regardless of above or below. The centerline is the 26 moving average. The dots are the 12 moving average. When they come together that is the same as the 12 & 26 colliding on that timeframe. That is what the midpoint is. The value of this is that the MACD is a very common indicator and other traders use it.
8. Remove the 'text and markers' from your screen. Use the toogle trades
indicator to get this from showing if you need to, but too much junk on the screen and once you make a trade, let go of it and this helps.
9. Put your commissions into NT. There are forum posts on how to do this. it is in options.
This helps you convert the thinking that SIM = LIVE.
1. Sim = LIVE, do everything in your power to believe this. You didn't show anything that caused me to think otherwise, but a bad habit just to not reinforce.
2. Record your whole screen. Hard to see it when you are bouncing out and in. Shouldn't be doing that while trading or bother with it while you are not trading either in my opinion. You don't need to sell us a course right now.
Focus on trading.
3. I didn't see your 100% ext. or real Fibs. Your fibs were all real small areas etc..
4. Know your keyboard shortcuts for a trendline, fib etc..
5. Have the larger target areas defined on your screen so it is like a plane landing or taking off. You are ready for it.
This is for both entry and exit. Maybe you do this on longer term charts which is fine.
I SAW NO TARGETS FOR YOUR ENTRIES!
6. What longer term charts are you looking at? Please explain. This isn't bad, just confusing to me..
Your targets should be coming off these areas and charts.
7. When you are coming from the top, the term is 'support' on the midband or 26MA MACDBB. When coming from below, RESISTANCE
8. You were not focused on the MACD's at the beginning. You went that way later and you were much clearer. Slow down, focus on long terms and settle in to an area to get interested. At first when it was moving quickly you were just trying to hold on with one arm and ride the bronkin buck. Relax, move your eyes off the 144 chart and settle in until you know you want to trade around here. I need some of my own advice.
9. You kept saying the market is "quick, quick, quick..." No need. The market is just the market. If anything you are slow. Just relax, no need to define that and just take your eyes off the charts, slow down your heartrate.
10. You mentioned trading is exciting. To me, trading is boring. Losing money while trading can be exciting until you are done for the day. TRADING = BORING.
11. You are focused on fundamentals "I'd like to help out those stocks and bonds" "I don't believe the economy is as bad...." Who cares, and as Big Mike has taught me, TRADE WHAT YOU SEE ONLY.
12. You said that trading is not for the 'faint of heart'. Why? You could dissect this and figure out what it means to you. Clear it out of your system.
13. Your entry on the first trade that was recorded was truly awful. Profitable but awful. That is where you will lose money in my opinion. Let it go and get the next one. Your other entries were much better after that, but that is the trade you want to erase even though it was profitable.
14. I didn't see a significant amount of price action. Few trendlines, channels, wedges, etc.. Something to work towards in my opinion, but you could have been doing them on your longer term charts, so...
15. You said once or twice "Lose Money". Take the word Money out of your vocabulary when you trade. This helps on the Psychological. Always talk in Points
if you can and not ticks
. Something Horst taught me well.
16. You are scalping
. Yes, you can make money scalping, but over the long term it will ware you down in my opinion and the goal is to grow larger trades if possible but do what you think is right.
1. Good Patience and explanations. You know what you are doing!
2. Good entries on the last 2 trades. I liked them, especially the last one.
3. You were exceptional to let the trend run out of steam and then look for a trade!!!
4. Good use of Fibs when you used them.
5. Very good attitude on the "More trades will come".
Again, please take this from my limited context
. My comments will get much shorter from here.