I missed the entire short move today. I have a project in Denver that has a conference call scheduled for 9:30am on Wednesdays. The time of the call is not my decision, but it almost never fails that when I have these types of calls they occur during the major move of the day.
Net 63 long, very cautious about it. Even though I can justify the reversal today, it was a beautiful move and I was not ready for something that spectacular today. I closed a long at a possible WC up, left at least 70 ticks on the table.
One more post if you are interested in trading crude. Confluence.
1) Major support zone
2) Confirmed support zone
3) Possible volume Exhaustion
4) Major LSP with good time distance
5) Momentum shift (see chart below) Least important of all, but still important.
Please register on futures.io to view futures trading content such as post attachment(s), image(s), and screenshot(s).
That highlighting shows the "higher low" I mentioned previously. I bought in the 94.60 something area, maybe 94.64?
I have set up my indicators on this one chart specifically to show when the balance is shifting. It does not produce "signals" as much as it creates "rules". Once that rolled over, up was the direction, because it was in major support.
How far, I'll probably never know. I obviously did not know today, I exitted around 94.90.
Last edited by GaryD; September 5th, 2012 at 06:52 PM.
The following user says Thank You to GaryD for this post:
The 30 minute chart with the fib projection makes that move today look like business as usual, but in real time it would be hard to go long in the face of a bar like that. Understanding the context would make a difference though. Higher TF support, uptrend, dipped below the prior days low and closed back up above. I've read that Richard Wyckoff used to say the large operators would drive the price below support like that to accumulate and then take the equity higher. The action fits that theory.
I've asked you this before, but LSP=Last significant pivot? Would the LSP be the pivot that was even lower?
Since the Inventory report is tomorrow instead of today I'm curious what is setting up. It wouldn't surprise me to see a continuation higher. It may dip first, but then up. We will see.
The following user says Thank You to David_R for this post:
Ego. Yes, a part of it. But also, if nothing else, a "goal".
The scalps I was taking I might have considered very high probability, but thwy were below what I consider high value. A lot were at the edge where price was showing hard momentum. I had over 30 one day, with 90%+ wins. But they were 4-12 ticks each? Maybe the 12s were decent, but 4,5,6... I don't know.
I get what you are saying about money is money. But get lazy as a trader, and you are toast. I felt the size of the scalps fell outside of what is worth the trade for some reason. Even though, I might be able to hit 90% wins with a stop larger than a target, some days. It just seems like there are so many other opportunities out there, why go for something so weak? And I believe the answer to that is, I made money a higher priority than I did trading "correctly". If there is actually such a thing.
I want the odds in my favor, on as many levels as I can get. Yes, I have done extensive study on the probabilities for a 6-range chart. Scalping for 12-15 ticks, or making that a target #1, increases the odds on a 6-range. Exitting around 30-40, also an odd increaser. Holding beyond 50, odds greatly diminish, like fall off a cliff diminish. But sometimes I want the market to turn before I get in, and the 30-40 tick range is top to bottom. Same with the 12-15. And when I see 10 ticks up and pounding for more, I grab some that I think feel "easy". Sometimes with a 6 tick target and a 12 tick stop. Because I had already seen what seems to lie in the way of my stop. Or, so I believed at that particular moment.
I read about scalpers, 20-30 lots, making 7 figures. But I have not met one, at least that I know of. To date, I am the best trader I know personally. I just laughed at myself. Hard. Tears almost... Still trying to compose myself... But it is true.
There are far better traders on this website than me, I believe that completely. I read some now, I didn't for a long time, but there are some very interesting guys on here.
But, face to face, I am alone in my crowd. And I have learned to look at myself from the inside and the outside, and try to be the best teacher I can for myself, try to lead by example, try to step back and judge. And I feel the actions I was taking were getting off the correct path, and the market was rewarding me to do so. And decided to back off. I got lucky is how I leave it.
I don't mean to reference someone with a negative inflection, but I posted a question about scalping being ok, and got a thanks from "Devil Man". Nothing wrong with that, I appreciate the thank you, and I don't mean anything against whoever that is. But the symbolism for me was pointed. Or maybe I just choose to see it that way. But either way, if that is my interpretation, I will trust myself.
Part of what I see as the process of becoming a trader, I mentioned to @greenr a few days back, it's almost functioning on a similar concept as how boot camp is designed to break you down so it can build you back up. We eventually make so many mistakes that we are scared to do anything. And then, slowly but with great hesitation, we might venture back out into areas where we dared not go again, but this time as a different person. I think that is where I am regarding scalping; what is it? why do it? is it worth it? is it "ok"? It would have eaten me alive at one point, but not as likely to do so today. That does not mean it is a good practice to keep. It may not mean it isn't.
Some day, maybe I will know with certainty who I am as a trader. Or, I will just accept that never really knowing anything is as good as it gets. I think I keep my scalping tools sharp because I may never know whether I need them or not.
I swear that staying sharp there allows me to get some great runs as well. Nothing makes the awareness sharper than trying to feel every tiny flutter. As practice, anyway. Then at some point you need to turn off the noise though. And maybe I saw that my attention was more on the noise than on the big picture. That is the true fault in the scalping mentality.
Thanks for the conversation. You offer good input. Don't take my debate as not listening.
Last edited by GaryD; September 5th, 2012 at 08:09 PM.
The following 2 users say Thank You to GaryD for this post:
Yes, trading smarter instead of bigger. That is where scalping fails. It is easier, and the setups come far more frequently. It feels like an endless stream of opportunities. And I guess it can be. But to me the pursuit of becoming a trader is to gain a higher understanding, at which point you can see the larger perspective and take advantage of it with more authority.
Much of the time I do go for longer moves. My "longer" is 20-40 ticks today, but I study the major moves 24/7. But last month I was way off. I got out of synch Mike, and profitable or not, it was not the direction I am wanting to go in. Who knows what happened. I am human, I got caught up in feeling good.
The good thing is that as I questioned it, I also went back and studied it. Spent hours looking at how I traded last month. And decided, I was a slacker.
This site is a lot of fun for me. Keeps me communicating about what is going on. And then, because it is always a running conversation causes me to get so much out of it compared to if I were just keeping a diary. I have others to answer to.
The following 2 users say Thank You to GaryD for this post:
In real time, it IS hard to do. But, that is where the indicators come in. As much as I was aware of most of what I posted for you, while it was occuring, as familiar with it as I feel I am sometimes... I did not buy 94.40 on the 6-range (the pullback to the T3 crossover). Some days I might take something like that, but it is tough to do, and I missed the morning and was not feeling up to speed quite yet.
I don't know about how much manipulation there is. Naive maybe, but to me, I think of it as the washouts might not be as controlled as they might be anticipated. Not that they don't get a good push here and there.
There are traders who actually use crude oil. Sounds bizarre, I know . But, there is a price where buying makes sense.
LSP is Left Shoulder Pivot. Classic context is in a Head & Shoulders pattern, in the example I showed you it could be a H&S (inside a larger corrective pattern), but I use it to define a major pivot on that side that is not the absolute low. Often the "Head" is nowhere to be found, but between prior lows/highs there is this other point. When they are that obscure, the response is not as good most of the time. When they line up with time, like the one today, they sem to function better. More traders see them is my belief.
As far as the EIA tomorrow, crude is trying hard to make it's case for a base in the 94 area, and this may be the leg that does it. But right now I am just as interested in the ECB and later Draghi comments. There's the potential for a lot of news, and a lot of interpretation. To me, tonight, the chart is bullish, CL is aiming to take out 97.40. That could mean nothing tomorrow.