NexusFi: Find Your Edge


Home Menu

 





Scalping costs in Forex vs Futures or Stocks


Discussion in Traders Hideout

Updated
      Top Posters
    1. looks_one bluemele with 6 posts (1 thanks)
    2. looks_two Tundi with 4 posts (0 thanks)
    3. looks_3 MetalTrade with 3 posts (0 thanks)
    4. looks_4 Trankuility with 3 posts (0 thanks)
      Best Posters
    1. looks_one LukeGeniol with 1 thanks per post
    2. looks_two Linds with 1 thanks per post
    3. looks_3 mtaalamu with 1 thanks per post
    4. looks_4 Eric j with 1 thanks per post
    1. trending_up 25,706 views
    2. thumb_up 6 thanks given
    3. group 7 followers
    1. forum 24 posts
    2. attach_file 0 attachments




 
Search this Thread

Scalping costs in Forex vs Futures or Stocks

  #1 (permalink)
 
Trankuility's Avatar
 Trankuility 
California
 
Experience: Intermediate
Platform: FxTrade/Ninjatrader
Broker: Oanda/MBT
Trading: Eur/Usd
Posts: 269 since Jan 2011
Thanks Given: 54
Thanks Received: 151

I trade Forex and going for a small amount of pips (1-25) using leverage is my preferred method.

I use an ECN which of course charges a commission. So each trade I have to pay the spread + commission, which eats a bunch of profit.

I've heard some people mention that trading futures or stocks is the way to go if you want to scalp because the costs are less than trading FX. Is that true and if so, how big is the difference? Is there a website that breaks it all down and shows comparisons?

Thanks.

Visit my NexusFi Trade Journal Started this thread Reply With Quote

Can you help answer these questions
from other members on NexusFi?
Request for MACD with option to use different MAs for fa …
NinjaTrader
My NT8 Volume Profile Split by Asian/Euro/Open
NinjaTrader
NexusFi Journal Challenge - April 2024
Feedback and Announcements
ZombieSqueeze
Platforms and Indicators
 
Best Threads (Most Thanked)
in the last 7 days on NexusFi
Retail Trading As An Industry
67 thanks
NexusFi site changelog and issues/problem reporting
47 thanks
Battlestations: Show us your trading desks!
43 thanks
GFIs1 1 DAX trade per day journal
32 thanks
What percentage per day is possible? [Poll]
31 thanks

  #3 (permalink)
 
TheSeeker's Avatar
 TheSeeker 
Germany
 
Experience: Intermediate
Platform: MT4, StrategyRunner
Trading: ES,EUR/USD,Oil
Posts: 127 since Dec 2010
Thanks Given: 81
Thanks Received: 73


No easy answer to this question as it depends on your account size and the pairs you trade.

Oanda and Interactive Brokers offer a pretty good deal in spot fx !!

Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)
 
bluemele's Avatar
 bluemele 
Honolulu, Hawaii
 
Experience: Intermediate
Platform: NinjaTrader
Broker: ATC/TT, AMP/Zen-Fire, AMP/CQG
Trading: TF
Posts: 2,543 since Jun 2010
Thanks Given: 3,803
Thanks Received: 2,842

I disagree. There is an easy answer. FOREX is VERY EXPENSIVE compared to futures or Stocks.

Not even close. I have traded forex for 1.5 years and I decided to return to just futures because I wanted to scalp. People who scalp in FOREX are typically people who don't know how to get into trading the other markets etc..

I mention FUTURES to a bunch of Forex traders and they don't like the lack of liquidity, but dream about the costs of commission. However, FOREX is nice because you can play with Pennies.

Even an ECN on forex is almost a joke. Watch how much your B/A move when you place an order. Compare that to a market maker and you will find that your entries are considerably worse. I have traded about 3 ECN's and about 5 different market maker brokers with 10's of K's and in my opinion it is a challenging market to scalp comparatively, but a lower barrier to entry for most traders.

Visit my NexusFi Trade Journal Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)
 Eric j 
NY
 
Experience: Advanced
Platform: Esignal, MBT navigator
Trading: Currencies
Posts: 2,507 since Jun 2009
Thanks Given: 1,396
Thanks Received: 2,576


Trankuility View Post
I trade Forex and going for a small amount of pips (1-25) using leverage is my preferred method.

I use an ECN which of course charges a commission. So each trade I have to pay the spread + commission, which eats a bunch of profit.

I've heard some people mention that trading futures or stocks is the way to go if you want to scalp because the costs are less than trading FX. Is that true and if so, how big is the difference? Is there a website that breaks it all down and shows comparisons?

Thanks.

U sure both spread and commission ? I use MB trading for forex and pay $2.95 total per $100,000 each way. I traded 2 lots of eurusd( $20,000 ) today and the commission was 76 cents to get in . One contract of 6E would carry a commission of around $5 and each tick is $12.50 . Im not scalping forex though and dont place more than 1 or 2 trades a day or even a week .

Visit my NexusFi Trade Journal Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)
 
Linds's Avatar
 Linds 
Victoria, Australia
 
Experience: Intermediate
Platform: NT, MT4
Broker: NT
Trading: Bund , ASX 200
Posts: 417 since Jul 2010
Thanks Given: 982
Thanks Received: 533

I agree you are up against it scalping forex on low timeframes unless you stick with the euro which has a tight spread. My broker doesnt charge commission and the euro spreads are about 1 pip during Frankfurt/US session....But it is a very valid option for position or swing trades on many pairs.

Visit my NexusFi Trade Journal Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to Linds for this post:
  #7 (permalink)
 
TheSeeker's Avatar
 TheSeeker 
Germany
 
Experience: Intermediate
Platform: MT4, StrategyRunner
Trading: ES,EUR/USD,Oil
Posts: 127 since Dec 2010
Thanks Given: 81
Thanks Received: 73

You can definitely scalp the EUR/USD with total cost (spread+commission) of under 1 pip in spot fx at high execution speeds. I'm not speaking of the typical Metatrader ECN brokers though and account deposits are higher (25k-50k minimum).

Oanda often shows spreads of 0.9 pips in the EUR - no additional costs, execution lightning fast, no accout minimum !

Interactivebrokers often has a spread of 0.5 pips, commissions of an additional 0.4 pips for round turn going down to 0.2 pips the more volume you do, again very fast execution.

So it's a pretty close race imo.








bluemele View Post
I disagree. There is an easy answer. FOREX is VERY EXPENSIVE compared to futures or Stocks.

Not even close. I have traded forex for 1.5 years and I decided to return to just futures because I wanted to scalp. People who scalp in FOREX are typically people who don't know how to get into trading the other markets etc..

I mention FUTURES to a bunch of Forex traders and they don't like the lack of liquidity, but dream about the costs of commission. However, FOREX is nice because you can play with Pennies.

Even an ECN on forex is almost a joke. Watch how much your B/A move when you place an order. Compare that to a market maker and you will find that your entries are considerably worse. I have traded about 3 ECN's and about 5 different market maker brokers with 10's of K's and in my opinion it is a challenging market to scalp comparatively, but a lower barrier to entry for most traders.


Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to TheSeeker for this post:
  #8 (permalink)
 
LukeGeniol's Avatar
 LukeGeniol 
Italy (IT) Italy
 
Experience: Advanced
Platform: ATAS, R|Trader, NT8
Broker: Rithmic
Trading: CL, Brent, GC, TF
Frequency: Daily
Duration: Minutes
Posts: 1,499 since Apr 2010
Thanks Given: 408
Thanks Received: 985

I agree with @Blumele, scalping on Futeres is much better than on spot fx, the speed of execution is incomparable.
@Linds, what u don't pay in commission you will pay more on execution speed, and slippage.
The advantage of retail spot fx is the possibility of split the standard contract size, so is good for low capital account, and for swing traders, like does @Eric j that trades 'mini lots'(ie 1/10th), but the commission are little lower on standartd contract that in FX futures usually is bigger, like on 6E is $125.000 and u will pay about $4.50 rt, this is not for 6B(GBPUSD) where the contract size is half 6E but you will pay the same commission, so spot fx can be considered for trade many pair that you will not find on FX futures. At the and all depend on trading style and capitalization.

Take your Pips, go out and Live.
Luke.
Reply With Quote
The following user says Thank You to LukeGeniol for this post:
  #9 (permalink)
 
bluemele's Avatar
 bluemele 
Honolulu, Hawaii
 
Experience: Intermediate
Platform: NinjaTrader
Broker: ATC/TT, AMP/Zen-Fire, AMP/CQG
Trading: TF
Posts: 2,543 since Jun 2010
Thanks Given: 3,803
Thanks Received: 2,842


TheSeeker View Post
You can definitely scalp the EUR/USD with total cost (spread+commission) of under 1 pip in spot fx at high execution speeds. I'm not speaking of the typical Metatrader ECN brokers though and account deposits are higher (25k-50k minimum).

Oanda often shows spreads of 0.9 pips in the EUR - no additional costs, execution lightning fast, no accout minimum !

Interactivebrokers often has a spread of 0.5 pips, commissions of an additional 0.4 pips for round turn going down to 0.2 pips the more volume you do, again very fast execution.

So it's a pretty close race imo.

Yes, agree, you are limited to the primary pairs. EURUSD, USDJPY, and maybe AUDUSD or similar, but they are definitely USD based.

Oanda you have to use their software and I haven't seen it work like a DOM and I also haven't seen the ability to 'script', so from my understanding it is all Manual unless you do the passthrough feed through "SPYDER"?? (I can't recall) or buy their interface access for like 600.00 per month to do so.

Oanda hedges every trade I believe. IB will move on you and you think if you are only looking at their chart that that is what the real price is. Overlay different price feeds and execute different orders at the same time and you will find that ECN is a joke in a way. It shows how illiquid Forex really is.

If you go market on most futures, you will definitely get filled unless it is an unimaginable amount for which a retail trader would be involved. My point is that with ECN you will be market orders really, so for scalping and you need to get your small entry area, then Futures is better for being more precise.

But, I am not experienced besides NinjaTrader, Tradestation and MT4, so there are probably other interfaces that I am not familiar w/ that may be better.

I weighed it heavily when I decided to get away from MT4/Forex.

Visit my NexusFi Trade Journal Reply With Quote
  #10 (permalink)
 
Trankuility's Avatar
 Trankuility 
California
 
Experience: Intermediate
Platform: FxTrade/Ninjatrader
Broker: Oanda/MBT
Trading: Eur/Usd
Posts: 269 since Jan 2011
Thanks Given: 54
Thanks Received: 151



bluemele View Post
I disagree. There is an easy answer. FOREX is VERY EXPENSIVE compared to futures or Stocks.

Not even close. I have traded forex for 1.5 years and I decided to return to just futures because I wanted to scalp. People who scalp in FOREX are typically people who don't know how to get into trading the other markets etc..

I mention FUTURES to a bunch of Forex traders and they don't like the lack of liquidity, but dream about the costs of commission. However, FOREX is nice because you can play with Pennies.

What is the min deposit amount to trade futures? Any brokers you can recommend? I currently use MB Trading (for Forex) with NinjaTrader 7.


Eric j View Post
U sure both spread and commission ? I use MB trading for forex and pay $2.95 total per $100,000 each way. I traded 2 lots of eurusd( $20,000 ) today and the commission was 76 cents to get in . One contract of 6E would carry a commission of around $5 and each tick is $12.50 . Im not scalping forex though and dont place more than 1 or 2 trades a day or even a week .

I'm positive. I use MB Trading as well. You pay spread + commission. Spread is generally lower than many non-Ecn's, but you definitely pay spread. Usual spread amounts are comparable to Oanda spread.

Visit my NexusFi Trade Journal Started this thread Reply With Quote





Last Updated on August 25, 2012


© 2024 NexusFi™, s.a., All Rights Reserved.
Av Ricardo J. Alfaro, Century Tower, Panama City, Panama, Ph: +507 833-9432 (Panama and Intl), +1 888-312-3001 (USA and Canada)
All information is for educational use only and is not investment advice. There is a substantial risk of loss in trading commodity futures, stocks, options and foreign exchange products. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
About Us - Contact Us - Site Rules, Acceptable Use, and Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy - Downloads - Top
no new posts