That's what I was thinking. How can they be different? One trader's exit is another trader's entry.
For me I guess I'm part of the minority. I've found with my strategy, exits are easier. That doesn't mean
that I maximize every single trade but I hit my targets that I've defined in my plan and move on.
My strategy focuses on low risk entries. My stop is placed accordingly.
Also, my stop depends on my strategy. In a trending market that is imbalanced my stop is much wider than
in a rotating market that is finding balance. I'm pretty good at fading the market with a tight stop
in a ranging market.
The following 2 users say Thank You to Massive l for this post:
Do you mean you don't have a stop order in, and exit yourself manually?
In certain markets like FDAX, it can move 100 ticks or more in a matter of seconds. Which would cause large damage to anyones PnL if they did not have a stop in place, and even with a stop the slippage would be pretty nasty. (I think the FDAX is the most volatile of any instrument I have encountered)
Do you avoid these types of markets?
The following user says Thank You to Twiddle for this post:
Interesting....I though I was the only one using mental stops, I have the same exact answer as tigertrader on the stop issue. It's actually quite rare that I pay a price for it..and the couple of times it's happened I got it back usually the same day. If other people ask me I tell them to use stops however...I think when you get enough experience and know what's going on you can use mental stops. At some point with enough trades under your belt you know if a trade is worth cutting short or letting run. Some one with limited experience might not recognize that they are on the wrong side and it could wipe them out, so until they know these things they should have a hard stop somewhere.
The following 3 users say Thank You to kbit for this post:
Beginning traders should look at this statement and realize that not having a close protective stop and using an at the market order to close a position is the same as having a stop order to close to an entry, unless you are using a stop limit order then the stop order is a market order to exit the position so you are doing the same as tigertrader.
As I have stated using a critical stop is the only way to go and with the use of a DOM a simple click on your close button is exactly the same.
Learn to manually manage your trades around the volatility of the market you are trading. Before you trade a market you should spend weeks or months learning its ebb and flow, so you will know when it is time to exit a losing position with price telling you this and not a predetermined stop loss.
The following user says Thank You to iTrade2golf for this post:
Ok, I'm gonna throw a wrench in this large stop love fest. You have to qualify your statements with the style of trading you do, and what generally works for that style. I have traded the CL every day with a fixed 4 tick stop fixed 8 tick target. Yes, in this approach the entry is absolutely paramount. I don't believe stops should ever be chosen arbitrarily, they should be chosen based on market principles. My stops can be 4 ticks because I am trading the peaks of small swings. If I am entering at the close of the 4 range bar at the apex of a swing that will move 12 ticks, then with a target of 8 ticks, there is no reason for my stop to be much greater then the size of the 4 tick range bar that I am getting in on.
The notion that a 10 tick stop is too small for CL is outrageous if your trading style does not require it. If you need the market to move 30 ticks to get a 2:1 trade, then yes your stop has to be 15 ticks, but not if you only need 8 ticks for a 2:1 trade. I know my trading style is in the minority, but it proves that the generalized statements about stops do not always hold true, it all depends on your trading method.
Last edited by monpere; August 4th, 2011 at 04:04 AM.
The following 4 users say Thank You to monpere for this post:
I agree. But there are not that many scalpers left... If you have an approach that works for you, that's great. I doubt many are able to trade CL with 4 ticks stop, and over time I find it hard to believe one would be able to pinpoint an entry that precisely, even with such small targets... But if you do, that is quite remarkable!
CL has countless gyrations of 40 ticks or more, it usually has a 100-tick move or two. It has limited liquidity and slippage can be a problem, so it makes sense to go for larger targets and ride the waves you can. I would argue that you are leaving way to much money on the table.... I'd rather take fewer trades with larger targets, I prefer to lean back while trading...
Can I ask how many trades you have a day? And your win rate?
The following user says Thank You to Lornz for this post:
You must have read me wrong or Algos must be poorly designed as i do not get stopped out that often specially if my position is backed by volume at price or a nice balance area. My stop on the ES is no more than 1.5/2 points, Nasdaq no more than 2/3 points and TF around 6/12 ticks. I trade in that range for my stop losses.
So i repeat my question, we are in a down trending market, price bounce off a MA which has been holding quite well. I place my stop above the swing that just kissed that MA. What the hell is wrong with that (see chart) ?
The following 3 users say Thank You to trendisyourfriend for this post: