How to code a Simple Moving Average?

September 27th, 2010, 05:25 AM

I always thought that the SMA - the simple moving average - was one of the simplest indicators. But as it appears, it is not easy to code one that is working correctly.

Standard Formula

The standard formula for the SMA is well-known. You add up the input values for the last n periods and divide it by n. If you code this in NinjaScript it will essentially look like this:

Code

 
protected override void OnBarUpdate()
{
if (CurrentBar == 0)
Value.Set(Input[0]);
else
{
if (CurrentBar >= Period)
{ 
double sum = 0;
for (int i = 0; i<Period; i++)
sum = sum + Input[i];
Value.Set(sum/Period);
}
else
Value.Set((Value[1]* Math.Min(CurrentBar, Period) + Input[0]) / (Math.Min(CurrentBar, Period) + 1));
}
}

Recursive Formula

Now, NinjaTrader developpers are clever. They use a recursive formula which calculates much faster, as it takes the previous SMA, multiplies it with the period, then adds the new input value and subtracts the value n periods ago. The NinjaTrader SMA therefore looks like this:

Code

 
protected override void OnBarUpdate()
{
if (CurrentBar == 0)
Value.Set(Input[0]);
else
{
double last = Value[1] * Math.Min(CurrentBar, Period);
if (CurrentBar >= Period)
Value.Set((last + Input[0] - Input[Period]) / Math.Min(CurrentBar, Period));
else
Value.Set((last + Input[0]) / (Math.Min(CurrentBar, Period) + 1));
}
}

Now, theoretically the two formulae should give the same results. Practically, however, there are rounding errors that seem to have an impact on the results.

False Results

Let me show a simple example. I have coded a CurrentSessionVWAP for the RTH session of ES, and to please the eye, I want to smooth it with a 3-period-SMA. I only apply the smoothing with the fourth bar of the session, so for the first 3 bars the original CurrentSessionVWAP is displayed.

Blue: CurrentSessionVWAP
Yellow: Smoothed with SMA Standard Formula
Red: Smoothed with Default NinjaTrader SMA

Below are two identical charts. The only difference is that the first one has a lookback period of 5 days, while the second one has a lookback period of 65 days

Do you still think that it is easy to code a SMA?

The NinjaTrader guys did not succeed in my opinion. Or am I simply wrong?

September 27th, 2010, 07:37 AM

Check out TA-lib TA-Lib : Technical Analysis Library - Home

And read this thread: C# Sample for Moving Average

Particularly the last paragraph...

September 27th, 2010, 09:07 AM

Hi MAXSJ

Thanks for the information.

I have now tried different settings, even changed the recursive formula. Finally I found the real problem:

The recursive indicators only work, if you change the default settings to MaximumBarsLookBack.Infinite.

So all indicators with recursive formulae need to use this setting. This shows again the problem of NinjaTrader. Because NT 7 is still a memory hog compared to MultiCharts, developpers tried to reduce memory load. Correct results were sacrified to reduce the memory usage.

Empirical Finding

For every indicator that uses a recursive formula you would need to modify the indicator code and add the line

Code

 
MaximumBarsLookBack = MaximumBarsLookBack.Infinite;

in the Initialize section of the indicator.

This also applies to SMA and EMA. Once the change is made, NinjaTrader will use more memory, but the results will be correct.

September 27th, 2010, 09:14 AM

I believe @Richard from Move the Markets did some studies on a fast-starting EMA that does not require that kind of lookback, you wish to poke around his blog. I am not sure if he is still around or not.

Mike

October 20th, 2010, 08:04 PM

how difficult or what would it take to convert ninja based indicators to the Ta-lib library

How to code a Simple Moving Average?

Discussion in NinjaTrader

How to code a Simple Moving Average?