I agree, in that case this option is not attractive.
I am not a US citizen, so I did not think of this problem.
Another thing which came to my mind is, we want more or better, more effective, regulation/audits of brokerage firms so that our funds in our futures accounts are secured. But if regulators finally start to scrutinize brokerage firms in an effective manner, we will suddenly see further firms go down the drain and customer funds disappear (the funds were already gone, but then everyone would see it).
But if a solution similar to SIPC is adopted for futures accounts as well, then this might not be a problem.
The following user says Thank You to karoshiman for this post:
By the way, I almost forgot that my agreement with TradeStation is also with TradeStation Europe (together with the US entity). The agreement states that TS Europe is regulated by the Financial Services Authority in the UK.
I am currently in contact with TS customer service to find out what that means in terms of funds protection.
However, this is of no help for you US guys... thought, some of the international members here might be interested.
The following user says Thank You to karoshiman for this post:
Trading: Texas Grease, NY Harbor Blend, Hammond B-3
Posts: 303 since Jun 2012
Thanks: 123 given,
1,056
received
Only other solution I can think of for this problem is the old fashioned way - let the marketplace decide.
Everyone knows the market is more intelligent than any single trader or firm.
They offer CDS coverage for crazy things like banks and sovereigns.
Why not offer these products for FCMs as well?
The marketplace would then determine who the riskiest FCMs truly are - somehow I think this is more accurate than letting self-regulated regulators decide.
Insurance could then be structured by the market makers in the event of a payout event.
On the CTFC's website they state their mission and responsibilities: "The CFTC's mission is to protect market users and the public from fraud, manipulation, abusive practices and systemic risk related to derivatives that are subject to the Commodity Exchange Act, and to foster open, competitive, and financially sound markets."
According to a video made by Dan Roth, President of the NFA, they (NFA) are overseen by the CFTC. If they're both responsible for the same thing, it seems to me there shouldn't be a need for both. And why do FCM's pay fees to NFA? NFA is a "self-regulatory organization" and they are supposed to "safeguard the integrity of the futures market." So they do that by collecting fees from the very FCM's they're supposed to oversee? What is the benefit to the FCM to become a member of the NFA when we have the CFTC? Maybe they should be merged so the CFTC won't need additional funding to do their job if merging the two would give them more "manpower" they need to DO their job?
A friend of mine who is in the insurance business called and spoke directly to the compliance officer of the NFA. He was not able to answer any of the questions asked of him. My friend suggested that the FCM's should be required to purchase a bond to cover their exposure. There are many other companies who are required to purchase bonds/insurance to cover the liability of some of their employees including directors and officers of their companies. When I worked as a secretary for an insurance company over 30 years ago, I was covered under a bond. Why not brokerages? Even my townhome association carries Director and Officers Liability insurance.
When the compliance officer can't answer a few simple questions about how they "oversee" or safeguard the integrity of the futures market, I'd question his qualifications.
So, we have an overseer (CFTC) of the overseer (NFA) who oversees FCM's and (safeguards) the integrity of the futures market? I don't get it. I must be dumb. That's why I lost my money.
The following 2 users say Thank You to brevco for this post:
Just my speculation after this new video. Sr. , family, and the board of execs including the CFO and that "homemade" personal auditor all knew about it. Rumors were going around. The emails to all the employees during the last week was to help ally fears and to keep customers from leaving until the exposure..
The following user says Thank You to Cloudy for this post:
Stupid suggestion with giving the regulators more money to get more and better people. What I've read so far about this, and if this is true, you would need only common sense to figure out that something could be wrong here. As someone else said, why didn't they just call the bank?
Agree, that someone else must have been involved as well. Cannot imagine that Sr. was the only one...
Site Administrator Swing Trader Data Scientist & DevOps
Manta, Ecuador
Experience: Advanced
Platform: Custom solution
Trading: Futures & Crypto
Posts: 50,004 since Jun 2009
Thanks: 32,468 given,
98,283
received
That was most humorous. LOL... talking heads fighting with each other...
Money is not the answer... and I also don't think more "insiders" doing the regulating is the answer... answer is true accountability, checks and balances, and complete transparency.
My trading funds are frozen with PFG. I had a couple people independently suggest opening an account with Infinity Futures. Does anyone have experience with Infinity Futures or could recommend a good futures broker?
Hi I doubt SIPC member firms would be interested increasing their levies to support the futures guys. Bear in mind regulation for securities is much tighter than futures so the insurance premiums for futures would likely be significantly higher.
I just looked at the SIPC annual report for last year. They only have net assets of $200+ million as there are still huge accrued liabilities outstanding from the Bernie Madoff debacle. The latest annual report can be seen here:
Even if they setup a separate self funded SIPC type entity for futures the cost to the futures brokers will be significant. The insurance companies will charge significantly for the risk premium due to lack of regulation and clearly incompetent oversight. Whatever vehicle is used, a bond or insurance the premiums to insure "the wild west" will likely be astronomical.
I doubt these firms can ever afford it. Take one of my brokers AMP futures for example. Their net assets are reported to be $800k+, how do you think they can afford say $500k in insurance?
*WASENDORF SAID HE USED PHOTOSHOP, SCANNER IN FORGERY, U.S. SAYS
*WASENDORF SAID CHOICE WAS GO OUT OF BUSINESS OR CHEAT: U.S.
*WASENDORF'S STATEMENTS MADE IN SUICIDE NOTE, PROSECUTORS SAY
*PEREGRINE'S WASENDORF SAID `I HAVE COMMITTED FRAUD,' U.S. SAYS
While unable to successfully kill himself, it appears the CEO of PFGBest is even less successful at evading the police. As just reported,
*PFGBEST'S WASENDORF ARRESTED IN IOWA
*FED PROSECUTORS CHARGE IOWA FIRM CEO W/ LYING TO REGULATORS:AP
*PEREGRINE CHIEF WASENDORF CHARGED BY FEDERAL PROSECUTORS (with making false statements to the CFTC)
*WASENDORF FRAUD AT PEREGRINE LASTED 20 YEARS, PROSECUTORS SAY
Wow been doing it for 20 years and getting away with it. Regulators must be complete idiots.
"The day I became a winning trader was the day it became boring. Daily losses no longer bother me and daily wins no longer excited me. Took years of pain and busting a few accounts before finally got my mind right. I survived the darkness within and now just chillax and let my black box do the work."
No one is safe now, absolutely no one. Who knows what else is going on out there right under our noses. Its like the wild west out there. Anything goes.
Sounds like he is trying to take all the responisibility from others that might have been involved. How could other people in PFG upper management, not have known?
Saw on CNBC that Wasendorf did appear in court wearing a blue polo shirt and looking haggard. How does someone apparently in a coma only a few days ago, appear in court so soon? Was the coma a fraud also?
Platform: Abacus, Slide Rule, HP-65, Metastock, TOS, NT
Trading: Futures
Posts: 3,424 since Aug 2010
Thanks: 1,057 given,
5,841
received
Sounds like he hired some script writers from Hollywood to write this confession statement, so fake and scripted. An attempt to keep Jr. , his wife, other family members, other big boys and girls in Iowa, and U.S. Bank clean.
I say bull, his suicide was a fake, he is not alone, and authorities should look into the whole PFG gang affairs. They have substantial energy investments in Iowa (perhaps where the money was funneled to) in partnership with well connected Iowans and major Iowa's politicians in their back pocket.
It could be a conspiracy theory, but If our analytical minded authorities can't figure out this whole cover up, we need some help from MI5 and MI6 in this country.
The following user says Thank You to aligator for this post:
I thought he was referring to pulling the money out of a brokerage firm and taking the cash rather than moving it to another brokerage. I've transferred an IRA from one brokerage to another in the past.
The problem is, how do you know who you can trust? With my luck, I'd transfer my IRA to another brokerage and that brokerage would be shut down. It would be like those MFG accounts that were moved to PFG.
The day I found out about PFG I read that about a banker who swindled $17 million out of his bank customers, left a note/confession and disappeared. They're not sure if he left the country or committed suicide. They're looking for him, or his body. This happened in either Georgia or Florida.
Mostly agree. All their actions before the exposure incident was to prevent clients from leaving and keeping a good face. Now it's about leaving a personal legacy and Sr. deciding to be the sole fall guy, so clawback attempts can be hindered as much as possible legally from the rest of the conspirators. Similar to Madoff keeping silent.
I'm not so sure about the suicide attempt being fake. Maybe it was unexpected to the others.
You are absolutely correct. I have a friend who has been in the insurance business for almost 40 years and we discussed this very issue. He lost two accounts with PFG and he is hopping mad. He's calling for a meeting with his congressman next week....and I'm sure he'll give him an earful. An insurance company would have a vested interest in making sure proper audits are conducted and as you said, they would do the risk analysis. With all the "news" that has come out, with Sr. fudging the records/statements for 20 years....it doesn't sound like the NFA or the CTFC were doing their jobs......and it would seem that they were negligent and should be held accountable right along with Wasendorf. Maybe someone should investigate the CFTC and NFA! I can understand PFG flying under the radar for 2, maybe 3 years, but 20??!! The regulators had to have known about this a long time ago and maybe it's possible since he was on the NFA board he was given preferential treatment?
The following 2 users say Thank You to brevco for this post:
Nakachalet, I feel your pain. This is the 4th time for me. First was Blinder Robinson, then another small brokerage out of Baton Rouge when I lived there, then there was CMS Forex and now this. I blamed myself the first two times because I knew nothing about finance and trusted the broker. I lost my entire life savings twice! That's when I decided to take control and start learning/teaching myself to trade. I had to start from scratch. I saved every penny so I could eventually have enough to open an account and studied during every spare minute after I came home from work. It took me 15 years to get to this point. I thought doing this myself was the only safe way to insure I had a future retirement. After losing my last job 7 years ago to a corporate buyout, I decided to dive in and trade full time. Now this happens....and I'm no "spring chicken."
Keep your chin up, have faith and don't give up. We're all in this together.
The following 3 users say Thank You to brevco for this post:
Neil was my broker and I've spoken to him twice since the shut down. He said he was forming his own company and
asked if I could wait a couple of days until he got everything set up.
He was still there answering his telephone on Tuesday and he gave me his direct line if I needed to contact him. I never spoke to Neil since I opened my account about 4 years ago until now. I signed up through WCCI. I have to admit I admire the man for still answering his phone after being told he no longer had a job! He also told me he was due about $XX,XXX in commissions but was informed he wasn't going to be paid, but he was still there answering his phone!
Now that, to me, is dedication to his clients. He didn't sound angry, didn't try to put me off and didn't make excuses. He sounded genuinely concerned.
The following user says Thank You to brevco for this post:
uhmmmm....what are you planning to do with the FBI signature? Photoshop??
Can I help? I need something to keep me busy 'til I can open another account.
"One NFA employee lists on her LinkedIn profile interning at furniture manufacturer Allsteel and working at an Iowa bookstore as her only work experience before the NFA hired her as an auditor in 2008.
Another NFA auditor's job before being hired in June 2011 was as a pricing intern for Walt Disney World according to his LinkedIn page."
Makes me sick to my stomach.
"Brownie, you're doing a heck of a job."
Why can't we sue the NFA and CFTC for negligence? Because it would be locked up in courts forever?
That's horrible. Sorry this happened to you that many times. Glad to hear you fought through it. Before I started watching CNBC's "American Greed" I had no idea all these variations of broker ponzis' happened so often and for that much money and with so many clients losing life savings after life savings in all these schemes. It's like it's swept under the rug in the news for the most part or localized. Used to be a million dollars was a dream come true. Now these ponzi schemers go for tens or hundreds of millions or closer to a billion.
That makes two of us. They're very good at making excuses and pointing fingers at each other. There are so many layers in government agencies that there are plenty of others to blame. So rather than expedite a resolution, they waste time placing blame. And a call for Gensler's resignation? It is my understanding he is appointed by the president. I think he should stay right where he is, sit in the hot seat and be forced to endure the humiliation and disgrace....then after his participation in all this is exposed, he should be fired and not be given the opportunity to resign voluntarily. Yes, it would be tied up in the courts forever. Anything to do with the federal government takes twice as long to accomplish. And the attorneys are the only ones who will make out like a bandit.
The following user says Thank You to brevco for this post:
In light of the recent news concerning alleged improprieties at PFG, AMP wants to provide our customers with more specific details about our operations.
Financials:
AMP is one of the few FCM's today that does not engage in any business other than the processing of trades for Futures and Commodity Customers. We are not dependent on interest income or alternative investments for our profitability - we process electronic futures trades for our customers- it's our business.
What we do not do?
No proprietary trading
No Exchange Floor Trading - Positions Reported to Clearing Firm only every 15 minutes
(Only electronic exchange trades by AMP customers - P/L to the tick)
No exposure to mortgage backed securities
No exposure to European debt
No activity in OTC or Off-Exchange Trading (such as Forex)
No Naked Short Options Selling (Unlimited Risk) by AMP Customers
What we do?
AMP reports its financial position on a daily and monthly basis to NFA and CFTC.
Mitigate Market Risk/Exposure:
AMP risk controls are marked to the tick and tradable markets are limited to the major liquid markets - no exotic/illiquid instruments.
We take regulation seriously - Our History:
Zero Regulatory Actions against AMP (IB or FCM, since 2005 inception) by the neither NFA nor CFTC.
AMP Futures: BASIC Details
AMP Trading: BASIC Details
AMP Clearing: BASIC Details
Size:
AMP is the entire 24th Floor of the LaSalle/Wacker building in Chicago.
AMP 24 hour Help Desk is fully staffed - 15 agents during US trading hours and 4 agents during non-US trading hours.
AMP 24 hour Trade Desk is fully staffed - 4 agents during US trading hours and 2 agents during non-US trading hours.
AMP 24 hour Risk Department is fully staffed - 6 agents during US trading hours and 2 agents during non-US trading hours.
Should you have any direct questions not answered, please contact me directly via email: dan@ampclearing.com
From one of my brokers,I keep segregated funds due to the failures we all know to well. Spread out the risk of corruption that is blatant with some and our Gov failing us. Nothing new,faces are different.
Agree. I am not a legal expert, but as the industry pays these NFA fees for a service, namely protection, why should a law suit not make any sense?
Thanks for the links, very interesting stuff... Gensler and Corzine working at the same time at Goldman... it's an old boys network... I remember back when I worked at a small M&A firm, we hired a colleague from Goldman... I remember very well that he told me that the whole capital markets have been invented to screw the man in the street... seems like this is true in many different ways...
I am wondering whether the companies of the other NFA directors or other cases of PO Box bank statement verifications or the usage of small auditors are now scrutinized with more intensity... if they take this seriously, they would do it...
I was wondering also, how one can do this for 20 years from a psychological point of view... I mean, what kind of person do you have to be to do that? What are your thought processes and feelings during this time? How can you live with that for so long? Okay, finally he couldn't (if it was not fake, what I do not believe), but 20 years is a veeeerryyy long time...
A psychological profile of Wasendorf Sr. would be interesting... (though it will not help to get any money back)
brevco, thanks for your consent. Then your friend surely knows how insurance companies are working. They would never accept this (bad black'n white copies, hand written account statements, no further proof etc.).
And furthermore, how many times could you as an insurance advisor pay out an insure benefit just by oral statement before you would be sued for fraud? How many times did you get a loan just by submitting blottesque statements?
As long as it is just segregated customer money and the whole integrity of the us futures and bank industry, regulatory authorities and governments on stake, I am asking what else?
Here's an interview with James Koutoulas of the Commodity Customer Coalition recorded on CFRN. Most interesting part of the interview is the first 10-15 minutes. James spoke with some people at PFG and it is my understanding that with the assets that are frozen, James estimates that PFG customers should be able to get back between 55% - 70% of their funds. That does not include going after anything that Wasendorf might have embezzled so we might actually get whole once this fiasco is all over but who knows how long that will take?
CCC held a public conference call on the PFG situation on Wednesday evening. Koutoulas said that the fact that PFG assets have been frozen and the firm is in a Chapter 7 liquidation instead of Chapter 11 reorganization is a positive for customers. He also noted that the bankruptcy filing indicates that PFG has considerably more assets than liabilities, which is a positve for customers, though he added, "It is too early to tell [what assets are available to customers]."
Attorney Greg Collette who has been working with the CCC on MF Global stated that he would be filing a class action suit against PFG. Details can be found through the CCC website.
In other PFG news Bloomberg is reporting that U.S. District Judge Rebecca Pallmeyer appointed Michael M. Eidelman of Chicago’s Vedder Price PC as receiver, placing him in charge of the business.
Bloomberg is also reporting that distressed debt traders are putting a very low price on PFG customer claims. According to Bloomberg CRT Capital Group LLC is valuing those claims between 22¢ and 25¢ on the dollar.
I'm just a simple man trading a simple plan.
My daddy always said, "Every day above ground is a good day!"
The following user says Thank You to ThatManFromTexas for this post:
Peregrine Financial Group Inc, the regulated unit of the brokerage PFGBest, has filed to liquidate under Chapter 7 of the U.S. bankruptcy code, a court filing shows.
Tuesday's filing with the U.S. …
) are accurate, worst case scenario is that PFG customers will get 45% of their funds back to 100% of their funds.
The following user says Thank You to olobay for this post:
I also think that more money would allow them to hire people with experience instead of kids just out of college following a poorly designed checklist. Or does the NFA do that on purpose to protect it's dues paying members?
The majority of posters here if doing the PFG audit would have either noticed the hand written bank statement balance or would have directly contacted the bank to verify the balances. Or they would have noticed the Iowa PO Box address on the statement. It's just common sense. Do any banks use a PO Box address for important forms? I doubt it.
Looking for a futures broker and wonder whether the ratings from Atlas are valid?
I really like what I read about Matt and his team at Optimus, but Vision Financial is rated #50 by Atlas. That seems to be only marginally better than PFGBest/Peregrine …
"FBI agents said in court records that Wasendorf admitted to embezzling money from PFG for more than 20 years. They also show that agents were talking to Wasendorf at University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics in Iowa City on Monday, within hours of the suicide attempt."
Platform: Abacus, Slide Rule, HP-65, Metastock, TOS, NT
Trading: Futures
Posts: 3,424 since Aug 2010
Thanks: 1,057 given,
5,841
received
Does anyone really believe U.S. Bank did not know what was going on? They should be the first to notice a company with the size and activity of PFG should have more than just $5M in their segregated account. After all, banks know more about segregation than anyone, they would spot a disparity in no time.
Don't kid me, it is more than just Wasendorf. He is just the fall guy. Let's see if U. S. Bank provided any leverage to Wasendorf and his Iowan partners in energy investments.
I was in banking for 10 years. When I moved to Denver I transferred everything to ....US Bank. Over the years I learned more about other products and eventually transferred my 401K into an annuity at Midland. It guarantees never to lose the principal. So far, it's held true. When everyone else lost money with a market downturn, I didn't make money, but I didn't lose either. After my 10 year stint in banking, I went to work for the RTC when it was created to bail out the savings and loans. That's where I learned details about the corruption that brought the S&L industry to their knees. We liquidated their assets and re-packaged the mortgages and auctioned them to investors. My own father was a victim of an S&L shutdown. I couldn't tell him that his S&L was about to be seized, and I tried to "hint" that he needed to move to a bank. He didn't take the "hint." lol
There was talk way back then that the banks were next. When I moved here and bought my home, my mortgaged changed hands 12 times in 13 years through the sale of mortgage packages among all the banks (not S&L's). Through my experience at RTC, I knew what the banks were doing, but there was nothing I could do. Refinancing myself was no guarantee that I could keep my mortgage with the bank I chose to do business with.
I've often wondered if it is even possible for the FDIC to go bankrupt? All the talk about Romney and his offshore bank accounts.....have you ever heard of anyone with an offshore account who lost all their money?
We've already seen what's happened with many banks. I truly believe there's more to come...it's just a matter of time. In these times, sadly, I don't trust anyone who is charged with the responsibility of handling my money.
A while back I watched an interesting video on YouTube about whether or not there really is any physical gold in Fort Knox. They were saying that if there IS any physical gold, it doesn't belong to the US because the US has used it as "collateral" to borrow cash to pay its debts. On the other hand, how much of what is on YouTube can you believe? And I read over 20 years ago that China was slowly and secretly buying up as much physical gold as they could get their hands on. All this is so mind boggling to me.
Platform: Abacus, Slide Rule, HP-65, Metastock, TOS, NT
Trading: Futures
Posts: 3,424 since Aug 2010
Thanks: 1,057 given,
5,841
received
Darn it, another lie; "What Happens in Vegas Stays in Vegas." This one from then Mayor Oscar Goodman. Now our fine city is involved, as if we did not have enough of our own.
Read on:
CEDAR FALLS, Iowa --- Russell Wasendorf Sr. married his fiance in Las Vegas June 30, just nine days before he attempted suicide back home in Cedar Falls.
According to Clark County, Nev., records, Wasendorf and Nancy Paladino obtained a marriage license June 30, the marriage was recorded on July 6.
Paladino and Wasendorf had been engaged since last winter, with a wedding planned for August 4 at Bethlehem Lutheran Church in Cedar Falls.
A reception had been scheduled to follow at his home northwest of Cedar Falls.
Wasendorf had announced Paladino would manage the kitchen for the planned second myVerona restaurant in the Cedar Valley TechWorks complex.
A psychological profile? Who would pay for that? The taxpayer? He's obviously an insecure buffoon with a narcissistic personality disorder. As my relatives from the deep south would say, he's not worth the gunpowder it would take to blow him up!
Site Administrator Swing Trader Data Scientist & DevOps
Manta, Ecuador
Experience: Advanced
Platform: Custom solution
Trading: Futures & Crypto
Posts: 50,004 since Jun 2009
Thanks: 32,468 given,
98,283
received
It's a State law, or etc, that when someone tries to kill themselves they have to be held for observation for xx hours. I think that is what was happening.
Much of what goes on in business is built on "trust" and the good old boy's network. That's why regulatory agencies fail to do their jobs properly. There's always been the saying.....anyone can be "bought" for a price. Anytime you have humans involved, there is the risk of corruption. The ones who aren't corrupt never seem to last long in big business. And I'm sure there are some individuals who have high moral standards and integrity!
I think about the "threats" that some of these "good old boys" face. They have families to support too. They get put in situations that would be unimaginable to most of us, I'm sure. And some of them become victims themselves. It will be very interesting to watch things unfold as this investigation continues. We may never know the full story.
PFGBest regulator: New technology caught $100 mln PFGBest fraud
By Ann Saphir
CHICAGO, July 13 | Sat Jul 14, 2012 12:51am IST
(Reuters) - The National Futures Association, the regulator that PFGBest CEO Russell Wasendorf Sr. says he fooled for years, "caught" the fraud this week with new technologies, NFA's chairman told Reuters in an interview.
Wasendorf doctored paper bank statements from three different banks for 20 years to pull off the fraud, he said in a signed statement cited in a Federal Bureau of Investigation complaint on Friday.
The fraud came to a climactic end on Monday when Wasendorf tried to commit suicide near his firm's Cedar Falls, Iowa headquarters. He was hospitalized, and on Friday was arrested by FBI agents.
NFA started a new audit of PFGBest about two weeks ago and the regulator for the first time demanded Wasendorf allow its auditors an electronic, direct look at his bank accounts, NFA's non-executive chairman Chris Hehymeyer said in the interview.
Wasendorf gave NFA the authority to do so on Sunday, Hehmeyer said. On Monday, Wasendorf attempted suicide, leaving a signed statement in his car that detailed his fraud, according to the FBI complaint.
"They are the ones that uncovered this whole thing," Hehmeyer said, of NFA auditors. "If they hadn't caught him, it could have gotten a lot bigger."
I'm just a simple man trading a simple plan.
My daddy always said, "Every day above ground is a good day!"
The following 3 users say Thank You to ThatManFromTexas for this post:
Amazing the regulators are circling the wagons and acting like they did a good job. Next they will be handing out awards.
Have to love this quote "They are the ones that uncovered this whole thing," Hehmeyer said, of NFA auditors. "If they hadn't caught him, it could have gotten a lot bigger."
How could things have gotten much bigger or worse. Apparently of $200 million plus in customer funds there is only $5 million left in the account according to reports we have seen. I don't think Wasendorf could have gotten much more.
"The day I became a winning trader was the day it became boring. Daily losses no longer bother me and daily wins no longer excited me. Took years of pain and busting a few accounts before finally got my mind right. I survived the darkness within and now just chillax and let my black box do the work."
The following 2 users say Thank You to liquidcci for this post:
True I did not consider the potential forward losses if he kept going. But a guy fooling them for 20 years with photo shop they should not be congratulating themselves for catching him. They bear great responsibility for the $200 million loss imo.
"The day I became a winning trader was the day it became boring. Daily losses no longer bother me and daily wins no longer excited me. Took years of pain and busting a few accounts before finally got my mind right. I survived the darkness within and now just chillax and let my black box do the work."
Site Administrator Swing Trader Data Scientist & DevOps
Manta, Ecuador
Experience: Advanced
Platform: Custom solution
Trading: Futures & Crypto
Posts: 50,004 since Jun 2009
Thanks: 32,468 given,
98,283
received
Since he has been forthcoming on the confession, I really hope we get to hear details as to why he did this. Specific details, like the nature of the losses with his company, and how year after year those changed, etc.
Mike without endorsing anyone could I please ask you who your broker is and why you chose them. I am concerned right now and I have just begun to make progress.
"Without question, the current system in which customer funds are held at the firm level must be reevaluated," the world's largest futures exchange operator by volume said in a statement.
U.S. futures regulators approved new regulations on Friday to shore up protection of brokerage customer funds following last year's collapse of MF Global.
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission approved the rule on the same day that Russell Wasendorf Sr., the founder of another failed brokerage firm, PFGBest, was arrested on fraud charges in connection with allegedly misappropriating customer money.
I'm just a simple man trading a simple plan.
My daddy always said, "Every day above ground is a good day!"
The following 2 users say Thank You to ThatManFromTexas for this post:
This would not have helped in the PFG case as Wasendorf Snr was the one (and only) person signing off transactions on the segregated funds account anyway.
Quote from Reuters about new CFTC rule:
"A measure known as the "Corzine rule" would require top executives at futures brokers to sign off on major withdrawals from customer accounts. A major withdrawal would be considered anything more than 25 percent of a customer's excess funds."
The following user says Thank You to steve2222 for this post:
Like commonly shown in episodes of CNBC's American Greed, the ponzi perpretrator may not only be making wild massive losing bets, but making losing investments in other areas such as real estate or just plain siphoning money from the segregated accounts to fund his and his co-conspirators' lifestyle. Sr. had reportedly bought into a restaurant , some local factory, an incomplete industrial property under construction, and a private jet that cost at least $20 million. Probably there are also vacation homes, vehicles, yachts, maybe private land property and foreign bank accounts out there too. Plus the family and those inner circles' individual perks and trappings to maintain.
I wanted to share a different side to the PFG story, one about some of the cool people that worked there. PFG was pretty big on trader education and so recently they started offering 12-week introductory courses. They were free if you signed up in advance. You didn't need to have an account with them to participate (I didn't have one). They first offered Introduction to Futures, and then earlier this year added Intro to Forex and Intro to Options. Curt Wagaman taught Futures and Options and Steve Nurre taught Forex.
I signed up, a little skeptical at first, for the Forex class which started in March and finished a few weeks ago. It was very much like a college class. Two lectures a week, 90-120 minutes each, along with homework and exams, if you wanted the completion certificate afterwards. The focus really was on education. There was some PFG cheerleading of course, but no pressure. We even had guest lectures from Jimmy Young and Bob Iaccino.
Anyway, the summer Futures class was to start on July 10th, the day after the fraud was discovered. And the summer Forex class was going to start on the 17th. There was of course no class on the 10th as the instructors were out of jobs. But during the week both guys got together and then held an informational webinar on Friday.
As educators they didn't want to let their students down, so they decided to hold 5 week courses...for free. Futures is going to start on the 17th and Forex on the 24th. I was stunned that these guys would work for free like this. The core material should remain intact because you won't have any info about PFG and no midterm and final exam reviews.
The other reason for a 5 week course is because, as Steve Nurre said in the webinar, "I don't know where I'll be in 6 weeks..."
The following 3 users say Thank You to Zelek11 for this post:
Thanks Mike, just wanted to get a little insight from you on what your thinking is.
Thanks,
Hector
PS: Great room by the way, I have learned a lot here. And I really like the way you are very
interactive with your members and how you police the site to make sure "Vendors" do not invade.
This is disturbing: "CRT Capital has already swooped in and offered to buy up customer claims from Peregrine victims for 20 to 25 cents on the dollar. If nothing else, this is a sign that CRT is pessimistically handicapping the outcome of the Peregrine customer recoveries -- the lowest price CRT paid for MF Global claims was 60 cents on the dollar."
There is a lot of money to be made in teaching trading courses. I don't know Steve or Curt and as long as I've been with PFG I never took advantage of their courses/education. But, they are probably just as much in shock as everyone else over this mess. They are probably just trying to "stay in the game" and do something to stay busy/involved until they figure out their next step. It is quite possible they might start their own educational program when the dust settles (and charge for it). Or, they might move to another brokerage and take their educational/teaching skills with them. I've taken advantage of "free" education over the years and also spent big $$ for others. Some were good, some were not as good. But for anyone who just lost their job, to be willing to spend their time (possibly without pay), to help others is not a bad thing. I'm sure PFG had some good employees and their lives have been turned upside down too. The action of these two guys (Steve and Curt) speak to their personal integrity and the actions of Wasendorf are not necessarily a reflection of everyone at PFG. (This is just my opinion.)
And, Hedvig, I'm upset over this too. This is the 4th time I've lost money with brokerages over the last 30 years through no fault of my own. Two of those times literally wiped me out so I had to start over more than once. But I appreciate reading the opinions of others, even if I don't necessarily agree with them.
@brevco, I think it is important to note the MF Global and PFG situations are entirely different beasts. Bear in mind MFGlobal used client funds to collateralize a massively leveraged $6b sovereign debt bet caused by a new CEO who wanted to turn MF Global into an investment bank.
They took advantage of legal re-hypothecation rules to use client funds to back the broker's own trades and borrowing. It was in the agreements clients signed with MF-Global. That is why nobody went to jail from MF Global. This loophole needs to be closed. My understanding is the brokerage borrowing rules allow firms to use client money to buy assets in their own name. Goldman and many other investment banks have been doing this for years so using an investment bank as your broker may not be a good idea.
So with MF Global you had money transferred to various institutions (such as $600m to JP Morgan) that could potentially be clawed back plus I assume liquidations of the sovereign debt position in itself. In other words at the time of liquidation the liquidator knew there were assets to recover.
PFG
With PFG it was blatant theft of client funds with what appears to be minimal assets to recover. The offer from CRT may appear to be generous in light of this as the risk of recovery appears to be much lower than MF Global. The lawsuits could keep this going for 5+ years . This is no different to any distressed debt sale situation. The price is generally low and then increases if more assets will be recovered than first thought.
Cheers
DJ
The following 2 users say Thank You to djkiwi for this post:
I don't care what people write in a forum or what reporters write in their articles about the potential return of customer funds. I would rather believe James Koutoulas from the Commodity Customer Coalition, who helped MFGlobal customers get 80% back and who has said he will do the same for PFG customers. And in the interview on CFRN which I posted, he said that after having spoken with PFG employees, he believes that only with the frozen assets already in PFG accounts, we should expect to get anywhere from 55% - 70% of our funds returned. CRT Capital would not offer to buy debt for 20 - 25 cents on the dollar if they didn't think they could collect at least double from PFG.
The following user says Thank You to olobay for this post:
He will never get out for the remainder of his natural life that's for sure But what's the point? Hes already so old. I really think they should bring back the death penalty for financial crimes of this magnitude.